If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.
This looks a good series, attractively presented, and lovingly compiled. Is it not also slightly bizarre? The selections in this one seemed designed to provoke debate - not a bad thing in itself - but it is a very odd mixture. Buffy Sainte Marie, C J Chenier and the Meat Puppets are among the artists I admire but why choose these in particular?
There are many I haven't heard of - again not a bad thing and probably my fault - but I can't believe that Corridos De La Frontera, Lee Harvey Osmond, Sara Watkins, The Goodnight Loving or the Bastard Sons Of Johnny Cash are essential. Am I right or am I wrong? I look for Dylan, CSN, a whole host of Stax artists, perhaps Nirvana, and they are not there. What criteria am I missing or is the problem that I am looking for some?
Overall, this will come across as far more sour than I am towards it. Mostly my remarks are quibbles and personally I look forward to listening to it and learning more. I just don't feel though that when I've done so, I will have a clear outline of Americana. Maybe it is just too nebulous a concept anyway to be able to produce anything other than a very good, if contentious, starting point for the more and less informed.
In the possible words of one Oliver Postgate " Americana is what you make it .. "
Of course with any of these compilation exercises there'll be a deal of compromise of what can be acquired and I daresay serious cost
restraints. If Spotify and the like survive you may well wonder if there's a future for these collections at all ?
Yes, completely agree. It isn't clear to me actually how the sales of cds are holding up. People speak a lot about Amazon but how many now are hardly buying at all?
Well I don't buy very many records at all, nowadays. I sometimes succumb at gigs but at a flamenco gig the other night I didn't even bother to look at the merchandise on offer.
Now has Global, I wonder, heard a cheep from Max as to when he's back in the saddle ?
This clip is from the 1948 Jimmy Wakely western The Rangers Ride. Arthur is playing in the band but unfortunately the soundtrack is not Artur's fiddling.It i...
Comment