Originally posted by edashtav
View Post
Prom 15: Paul Lewis plays Beethoven’s ‘Emperor’ concerto – 25.07.18
Collapse
X
-
I listened this afternoon to the repeat of Tansy Davies’s new Suite for I feared that, perhaps, I’d be3n a little harsh in post# 21.
What I had failed to acknowledge was the lucidity and clarity of the BBC PO’s performance under Ben Gernon. How3ver, the music still failed to convince me. Itd subject , 9/11, is such a black one that one can’t expect even as much good cheer, as the hope that occasionally lightens R.Strauss’s Death and Transfiguration. But the enveloping grey fog, the disorientation, and the endless bleakness of Tansy’s fournmovements, have none of the variety and textural variation that one finds in the most desolate works of Shostakovich. There was insufficient rhythmic variety and interest and instead of the whole work building a cumulative intensity, it became tame, its teeth drawn by too much of the same, and the music’s idiom degenerated into them generic: late 20th century angst.
I do hope other Boarders find kinder things to say because Tansy Davies has been a force for hope in 21st British music and I want to believe that her best is yet to come.
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by edashtav View PostI do hope other Boarders find kinder things to say because Tansy Davies has been a force for hope in 21st British music and I want to believe that her best is yet to come.
Like you, ed, I hope that her best work is yet to come - hope against hope, in that so much of her recent Music makes me think that her best work is behind her. Did you hear Cave on last Saturday's Hear & Now? (I presume it's not a Latin title.) I missed the opera, but caught her "playlist" afterwards - it included some of my favourite living composers, which delighted me. I wish that there was a similar engagement with these composers demonstrated in her own compositions.[FONT=Comic Sans MS][I][B]Numquam Satis![/B][/I][/FONT]
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by Pulcinella View PostI'm wondering if we listened to the same second half!
Here at Casa Pulcinella we thought it rushed, scrappy, not well articulated.....didn't enjoy it very much!
Maybe the fact that it was my A-level set work (very) many years ago has something to do with it (but that doesn't explain my partner's feelings).
We both enjoyed the Emperor, though.[FONT=Comic Sans MS][I][B]Numquam Satis![/B][/I][/FONT]
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by ferneyhoughgeliebte View Post[...] Did you hear Cave on last Saturday's Hear & Now? (I presume it's not a Latin title.) I missed the opera, but caught her "playlist" afterwards - it included some of my favourite living composers, which delighted me. I wish that there was a similar engagement with these composers demonstrated in her own compositions.
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by edDon’t I recall hearing the Cave as composed by one of the American Minimalists at the South Bank, ten is so years ago? I think it was multi-media but remember it’s music as thin gruel.
Cave (no definite article, like Wigmore and Carnegie Halls) is about a post-environmental disaster world.[FONT=Comic Sans MS][I][B]Numquam Satis![/B][/I][/FONT]
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by ferneyhoughgeliebte View PostThe Cave is the video opera Steve Reich and his wife Beryl Korot, ed - I dunno about the South Bank, but it was done at Huddersfield over twenty years ago. It uses the recorded speech samples technique that Reich had previously used in Different Trains, and the title refers to the joint origins of Judaism and Islam.
Cave (no definite article, like Wigmore and Carnagie Halls) is about a post-environmental disaster world.
So what about the Liverpool nightclub? Oh no, that's The Cavern.
So where's "Cavern"?
Comment
-
Comment