Originally posted by jean
View Post
General election results 2015
Collapse
X
-
-
-
Originally posted by french frank View PostI hope so, since it says younger people tend to be opposed.
But I see no reason to consult the electorate on what electoral system is used. They weren't consulted on FPTP. Nor do I think they should be consulted on whether we have the death penalty.I have a medical condition- I am fool intolerant.
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by James Wonnacott View PostOf course not, Nanny knows best.
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by Serial_Apologist View PostI must admit to not having understood what french frank wrote in that message either. After all, a high premium on the importance of community political involvement surely must extend to the methods by which any decision making will be expressed.
I'm not sure that the actual system used to vote needs to be the subject of a referendum (as AV was). There are many other electoral rules and regulations where we don't vote every time there's a change. You could extend the Nanny comment to anything which any government decides to do without a specific vote having taken place first.
It's when one gets to the point where people are persuaded that PR is unfair because 'some people get two votes' that one feels a referendum isn't wise.
PS Actually, it wasn't the EU - it was the death penalty, wasn't it?It isn't given us to know those rare moments when people are wide open and the lightest touch can wither or heal. A moment too late and we can never reach them any more in this world.
Comment
-
-
Not the result I wanted but there is a sort of poetic justice to what has happened to the Liberal Democrats.
They pretended to be principled, when in fact they were just greedy for office: Clegg sold his soul for (not a lot of) power and now he must survey his vastly diminished kingdom from his lonely South Yorkshire redoubt.
Paddy Ashdown was very funny (albeit unintentionally) on the exit poll: this man has been consistently WRONG about every major issue since h e entered politics.
I've long felt that the LDs are a joke party: a bunch of people who 'like' the idea of political involvement but have no idea what political involvement actually involves.
Well: they've helped to birth a right-wing Tory government and have placed themselves further from the levers of power than at any time since 1970.
It's hilarious. :)
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by Conchis View PostNot the result I wanted but there is a sort of poetic justice to what has happened to the Liberal Democrats.
They pretended to be principled, when in fact they were just greedy for office: Clegg sold his soul for (not a lot of) power and now he must survey his vastly diminished kingdom from his lonely South Yorkshire redoubt.
Paddy Ashdown was very funny (albeit unintentionally) on the exit poll: this man has been consistently WRONG about every major issue since h e entered politics.
I've long felt that the LDs are a joke party: a bunch of people who 'like' the idea of political involvement but have no idea what political involvement actually involves.
Well: they've helped to birth a right-wing Tory government and have placed themselves further from the levers of power than at any time since 1970.
It's hilarious. :)
Comment
-
-
I've got a new desktop picture of David Cameron's first cabinet meeting. Around the table with him are George Osborne, Darth Vader, Blofeldt, Cruella De Vil, Voldemort, etc. It cheers me up to know I'm not alone in my utter despair.Last edited by Eine Alpensinfonie; 12-05-15, 22:07.
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by Eine Alpensinfonie View PostI've got a new desktop picture of David Cameron's first cabinet meeting. Around the table with him are George Osborne, Darth Vader, Blofeldt, Cruella De Vil, Voldemort, etc. It cheers me up to know I'm not alone in my utter despair.
It was genuinely funny listening to the squeals of outrage from the rag tag and bobtail army of people who had split the anti-Tory vote by voting for the Greens, the Scots Nats and other parties that stood not a change of achieving real power. These people seem to have forgotten that we DON'T live under PR, which was deciively rejected by the electorate in 2011. There won't be another referendum on AV in any of our lifetimes.
I fully expect a Conservative government to be in power for the rest of my life (and I'm 'only' 47), largely because of the Left's inability to come up with convincing alternative arguments/figures.
'Progressive' politics in Britain is as dead as a thousand dodos.
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by french frank View Post...But I see no reason to consult the electorate on what electoral system is used. They weren't consulted on FPTP. ...Originally posted by french frank View Post...It's when one gets to the point where people are persuaded that PR is unfair because 'some people get two votes' that one feels a referendum isn't wise. ...
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by Eine Alpensinfonie View PostAre you making the assumption that the UK is a synonym for England?
In Wales, the Tories made their biggest gains in forty years.
My point is that the WHOLE of the UK has swung to the right - the direction in which it naturally inclines, anyway.
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by Conchis View PostNo: the rejection of independence signified the 'conservative' mood in Scotland. The fact that they have now gone massively for the SNP (not a Party with a socialist agenda, as some people mistakenly believe) means nothing other than that the Scots, having made a practical decision and binding decision nine months ago, have now followed it up with an emotional (and non-binding) one.
In Wales, the Tories made their biggest gains in forty years.
My point is that the WHOLE of the UK has swung to the right - the direction in which it naturally inclines, anyway.
If the SNP doesn't have a socialist agenda, what does it have? It certainly isn't right wing by any normal definition of "right wing". Scotland has not "swung to the right". It has swung from a labour party that swung to the right and stood shoulder to shoulder with the tories during the referendum campaign.
Comment
-
Comment