Originally posted by Flosshilde
View Post
Not like the rest at all ?
Collapse
X
-
Richard Barrett
I am wondering what Hilaire Belloc has to do with that little poem. Did he like green eggs and ham or something?
Comment
-
Originally posted by Richard Barrett View PostI am wondering what Hilaire Belloc has to do with that little poem. Did he like green eggs and ham or something?
I do not like thee, Dr. Fell
The reason why I cannot tell
But this I know and know full well
I do not like thee, Dr. Fell.
was by Belloc but, even if indeed so attributed, I see now that it long predates him.
Apologies!
Comment
-
-
Richard Barrett
Originally posted by P. G. Tipps View PostLooks like the work of a poetess to me, though it may not be particularly PC to say so ...
Comment
-
Poetess is one of those gendered terms that implies a lesser status than its male counterpart, and for that reason it has dropped out of use.
Mt Tipps of course thinks the word is not used as a result of political correctness, but I think women poets may be allowed to be addressed however they prefer.Last edited by jean; 18-12-14, 18:55.
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by Richard Barrett View PostYour mental processes are exquisitely weird, I must say - why do you have that impression, pray tell? and what gives you the idea that it might "not be particularly PC to say so"?
As to your first, let's just say an educated hunch on the available evidence!
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by jean View PostPoetess is one of those gendered terms that implies a lesser status than it ms male counterpart, and for that reason it has dropped out of use.
Mt Tipps of course thinks the word is not used as a result of political correctness, but I think women poets may be allowed to be addressed however they prefer.
So logically you would refer to the Duke of Cambridge/Prince Kate and not the Duchess of Cambridge/ Princess Kate ...?
A tad confusing for the world's royal-watchers, maybe ...?
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by P. G. Tipps View PostWell of course only one lucky person knows what Mr Tipps thinks!
So logically you would refer to the Duke of Cambridge/Prince Kate and not the Duchess of Cambridge/ Princess Kate ...?
A tad confusing for the world's royal-watchers, maybe ...?
the word "poetess" has gone out of use
in the same way that Actors can be male or female
and
I'd refer to those folks you mention as 'benefit scroungers'
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by P. G. Tipps View PostWell of course only one lucky person knows what Mr Tipps thinks!
So logically you would refer to the Duke of Cambridge/Prince Kate and not the Duchess of Cambridge/ Princess Kate ...?
However if it's hardly ever used - and you're well aware of this, as you make clear - then using it makes a particular point.
If for example you refer to Marin Alsop as a conductress, conclusions will be drawn about your opinion of her. You need to be aware of that, as presumably you are - or you wouldn't have brought up your little obsession, again.
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by jean View PostDidn't you tell us yourself it was a matter of political correctness?
If a feminine form is in common use, it isn't marked, and there's nothing odd about using is.
However if it's hardly ever used - and you're well aware of this, as you make clear - then using it makes a particular point.
If for example you refer to Marin Alsop as a conductress, conclusions will be drawn about your opinion of her. You need to be aware of that, as presumably you are - or you wouldn't have brought up your little obsession, again.
The fact that you appear to object to the musician's gender being instantly noted suggests it might well be you that harbor's some sort of 'obsession' rather than myself?
Comment
-
Comment