Private Passions turn-off

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Cornet IV
    • Dec 2024

    Private Passions turn-off

    I've held my fire in the expectation that there might be others sharing my reaction to yesterday morning's broadcast but I've not found a kindred spirit. I can't possibly be alone, can I; the only one listening to Radio 3 at 10.45?

    Being significantly deaf makes understanding announcers' blurb difficult (particularly since the Beeb adopted estuary english) so I'm a little unsure of what was said but I think the noise made was created by a chap called Steve Rice. Now, I readily acknowledge that whilst this piece of the programme was entirely characteristic of the worthless tripe that self-absorbed BBC producers like to include to demonstrate their avant garde credentials, it was, in fact, requested by a guest of the programme, so Auntie might be thought blameless.

    Not so! I have a deeply-rooted objection to being irritated by such a wretched example of "progressive" and, no doubt, "inclusive" tastes of programme guests when their choice is so-called music that is repetitive, devoid of any artistic value, quite meangingless, wholly without merit and inexcusably boring as was the case yesterday. Auntie as an accessory before and during the fact is indeed culpable. In order to avoid the ire of mentally stable, licence fee-paying listeners, the guest should have been persuaded to select something different. But I'm forgetting - the producer probably loved it.

    Bah!
  • vinteuil
    Full Member
    • Nov 2010
    • 12936

    #2
    ... I think Cornet IV didn't particularly enjoy Steve Reich's 'Music for Mallet instruments voices and organ'.

    Well, it does date from 1973, so I agree that this forty year old classic may be showing its age a little by now...

    Comment

    • MrGongGong
      Full Member
      • Nov 2010
      • 18357

      #3
      Originally posted by vinteuil View Post
      ... I think Cornet IV didn't particularly enjoy Steve Reich's 'Music for Mallet instruments voices and organ'.

      Well, it does date from 1973, so I agree that this forty year old classic may be showing its age a little by now...
      OH come on
      "Mallet instruments, voices and Organ" is (IMV) one of his greatest pieces
      written before he started to become the 'famous composer'
      a real classic and much better than many of the things that followed it .......


      (Though surely Steve Reich should only be in the afternoon ? ........... )

      I'm reading this at the moment


      Great stuff .........

      Comment

      • Serial_Apologist
        Full Member
        • Dec 2010
        • 37814

        #4
        Originally posted by MrGongGong View Post
        OH come on
        "Mallet instruments, voices and Organ" is (IMV) one of his greatest pieces
        written before he started to become the 'famous composer'
        a real classic and much better than many of the things that followed it .......


        (Though surely Steve Reich should only be in the afternoon ? ........... )

        I'm reading this at the moment


        Great stuff .........
        Does the author succeed in justifying the success of failure, or fail in justifying the failure of success?

        The first time I came across the expression "negative capability" was in the Woody Allen film "Manhattan".

        Comment

        • decantor
          Full Member
          • Dec 2010
          • 521

          #5
          Originally posted by Cornet IV View Post
          I've held my fire in the expectation that there might be others sharing my reaction to yesterday morning's broadcast but I've not found a kindred spirit. I can't possibly be alone, can I; the only one listening to Radio 3 at 10.45?
          No, not alone. Wasn't the requesting guest a psychologist or psychiatrist of some sort? I thought he must be using his choice to drum up some business. I was moved........ first to the outer edge of sanity, and soon after to the off-switch.

          Strange, though. I've heard some Reich that I rather liked, but this bit was Chinese torture.

          Comment

          • Thropplenoggin
            Full Member
            • Mar 2013
            • 1587

            #6
            This was discussed in depth on the 'Essential Classics' thread, starting with my witticism here: http://www.for3.org/forums/showthrea...696#post303696
            It loved to happen. -- Marcus Aurelius

            Comment

            • Cornet IV

              #7
              Originally posted by MrGongGong View Post
              OH come on
              "Mallet instruments, voices and Organ" is (IMV) one of his greatest pieces
              written before he started to become the 'famous composer'
              a real classic and much better than many of the things that followed it .......
              Well, Mr GG, given that I am in no sense qualified to dispute the validity of your view, I can only be grateful that I have not been subjected to anything of this chap's "famous" period.

              Comment

              Working...
              X