Originally posted by cloughie
View Post
Phrases/words that set your teeth on edge.
Collapse
X
-
Originally posted by Padraig View PostIt's not a teeth on edge matter but I can't help balking at the phrase 'and nor' when I hear it. I have neither used it myself and nor would I find it comfortable to do so. (That looks/sounds awful to me).
When would 'and nor' be correct?
I would not say it; nor would my partner.
I would not say it, and nor would my partner.
But perhaps your specific concern is the neither......nor construction.
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by Padraig View PostIt's not a teeth on edge matter but I can't help balking at the phrase 'and nor' when I hear it. I have neither used it myself and nor would I find it comfortable to do so. (That looks/sounds awful to me).
When would 'and nor' be correct?It isn't given us to know those rare moments when people are wide open and the lightest touch can wither or heal. A moment too late and we can never reach them any more in this world.
Comment
-
-
It's the "and" that's unnecessary, isn't it? (Genuine, not rhetorical, question):
"I would not say that; neither would my partner; nor would anyone I know."
Unless you wanted a rhetorical emphasis:
"I would never do that, and neither would my partner, and nor would any decent-thinking person."
(Although even here "and neither would any decent-thinking person" seems more emphatic that "and nor" in that example. In fact, that's what I originally wrote rather than "and nor", which doesn't come "naturally" to me. )[FONT=Comic Sans MS][I][B]Numquam Satis![/B][/I][/FONT]
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by kernelbogey View PostThis is creeping into BBC speak
E.g. [made up examples] 'MPs are returning to Westminster in what is the last week before the summer recess.'
'Andy Murray is preparing for what is his final match.'
I listen in vain for what this phrase adds to the meaning.
'Andy Murray is preparing, for what is his last match?'
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by Serial_Apologist View PostPerhaps some additional punctuation would improve matters; e.g.:
'Andy Murray is preparing, for what is his last match?'
In my first, made up, example, the alternative might be
'MPs are returning to Westminster in the last week before the summer recess.'
But that then lacks the emphasis the writer (for 'tis all written) sought, which I take to be something along the lines of
'MPs are returning to Westminster: it's the last week before the summer recess [and by Jove they've got a lot still too do].'
I heard the phrase a couple of days ago in a weather forecast, but of course can't now remember the exact words.
I'm not sure that my first instinct that it is a redundant phrase is altogether accurate.
Watch this space on what is still a dark morning here.
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by Serial_Apologist View Post"They should just get on with it".
The parrot - sorry, speaker - never explains how, however - probably because he or she has no idea how, hasn't given much if any thought as to the consequences, and possibly doesn't even care.
A similar one, which was said to me, “why don’t you just get on and teach us?”. Said by someone who thought teaching was me telling “them” and they would somehow absorb the “facts”, techniques and methods.
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by Padraig View PostIt's not a teeth on edge matter but I can't help balking at the phrase 'and nor' when I hear it. I have neither used it myself and nor would I find it comfortable to do so. (That looks/sounds awful to me).
When would 'and nor' be correct?
Returning to “and nor”, possibly the “and” gives the speaker just a little more time to formulate the rest of the sentence, and the listener more time to absorb it. It seems likely that “nor” by itself should suffice, and in some cases even “and” by itself.
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by kernelbogey View PostWell... since emphasis is another for this listener, I'm really unsure whether that would improve matters.
In my first, made up, example, the alternative might be
'MPs are returning to Westminster in the last week before the summer recess.'
But that then lacks the emphasis the writer (for 'tis all written) sought, which I take to be something along the lines of
'MPs are returning to Westminster: it's the last week before the summer recess [and by Jove they've got a lot still too do].'
I heard the phrase a couple of days ago in a weather forecast, but of course can't now remember the exact words.
I'm not sure that my first instinct that it is a redundant phrase is altogether accurate.
Watch this space on what is still a dark morning here.
Comment
-
Comment