Annoying R3 Trailers

[kernelbogey]

Very abused word “immersive.” It’s used to mean music to relax into and let all other thoughts leave your mind....

This is the current R3 marketing ploy - flogging Classical music as a meditative crutch. There are many interpretations of mindfulness, but I don't consider listening to music per se to be mindful - nor, I believe, did the Buddha! Just as the bathwater is not in itself immersive, nor is music mindful. Both require the actions of the bather or the meditator.

[kernelbogey]

Would that be John Sykes?

It was - though without your post I would never have remembered. He worked for OUP (and didn't read The Times!).

[LMcD]

It was - though without your post I would never have remembered. He worked for OUP (and didn't read The Times!).

12-times winner Mark Goodliffe 'suffered a shock semi-final defeat' last year, but says he'll be back.

[cria]

Curiously, since becoming a gentleman of leisure I have better things to do...

... a proper GOL would never ever say he's a GOL. - he will exude it ...

[antongould]

Mildly ironic that on Breakfast yesterday - Squire Trelawny had a huge moan about how advertisements were taking over our everyday lives ….

[Frances_iom]

The Squire has been mentioned in numerous adverts on R4 in what appears to be a push to get more listeners to R3

[Roger Webb]

The Squire has been mentioned in numerous adverts on R4 in what appears to be a push to get more listeners to R3

Yes at about ten to nine every day....as if Radio 4 doesn't want us to listen to what's on at nine - Thurs...In Our Time; Fri...Desert Island Discs - some justification there!

[oddoneout]

A couple of days ago I happened to switch the radio on when I came down for breakfast - I was not completely with it at the time - and in due course heard what I assume is the revised version of one of the ads, asserting that R3 is the home of live classical music [my bold although it was slightly stressed by the announcer]. Couldn't help thinking that it is convenient a) that 'live' no longer means what it used to and b) that they can get away with that claim as no-one else broadcasts live(as in not recorded in some way) classical music?

[Serial_Apologist]

A couple of days ago I happened to switch the radio on when I came down for breakfast - I was not completely with it at the time - and in due course heard what I assume is the revised version of one of the ads, asserting that R3 is the home of live classical music [my bold although it was slightly stressed by the announcer]. Couldn't help thinking that it is convenient a) that 'live' no longer means what it used to and b) that they can get away with that claim as no-one else broadcasts live(as in not recorded in some way) classical music?

One wonders what the home of dead classical music would be like.

[oddoneout]

One wonders what the home of dead classical music would be like.

R3 after another SJ refresh...

[smittims]

To me, 'dead' classical music is the opposite of what R3 is offering: the equivelent of 'dead' languages: vintage (or 'classic' or 'historic') recordings of complete pieces , played by artists closer to the composers than today's young hopefuls; most of my own listening, in fact. For me,the absence from R3 of the artists of the past is the biggest sign of dumbing-down on Radio 3, where, for Elizabeth Alker 'way back in time ' means 1999.

[Kernow Malc]

"Red Nose Day is back..." Click - OFF. So much for popping back to the station.

[smittims]

If they wanted to discourage me from taking part in red nose day they couldn't do it more effectively than with that repulsive trailer.

[Ein Heldenleben]

If they wanted to discourage me from taking part in red nose day they couldn't do it more effectively than with that repulsive trailer.

It’s completely inappropriate to Radio 3 isn’t it ?
sometimes I wish people were aware of what many in the corporation think about these charity days. They bend the BBC’s editorial guidelines to breaking point , are often sloppy in production terms and full of second rate lacklustre material, sickeningly sentimental, and are a magnet for the publicity obsessed and sometimes frankly mad. But in the words of Smashy and Nicey “it’s all for charidee mate …”

I guess they raise millions and that’s the excuse , But is that just money taken away from other charities?

[LMcD]

I guess they raise millions and that’s the excuse , But is that just money taken away from other charities?

I suspect that some people's definition of 'charitable giving' may be limited to an annual donation of £25 on Red Nose Day. and putting unwanted 1p and 2p coins in collecting tins.