Amazon reviews

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Dave2002
    Full Member
    • Dec 2010
    • 18035

    Amazon reviews

    I sometimes write Amazon reviews. Sometimes I can't remember whether I've written a review before. I think there used to be a way of filtering the reviews to find one's own previous reviews, but maybe that doesn't work any more. Is there a way to check? I'm not even sure that looking at one's own order indicates whether a review has been written previously, or not.

    Also, sometimes it's hard to write a sensible review because of the way Amazon may group similar products together. For example, Brand X models A and B may be good, and deserve a 4 or 5 star review, but then Amazon goes and puts Brand X model C on the same web page, and model C is in fact a rather different and considerably poorer object only deserving a 1-3 star review. Sometimes I write new wording to indicate that, but it is not at all helpful. One item may be a 5 star item, another a 1 star. Should one go down the middle and give 3 stars?

    One finds that other reviewers also have similar issues, as when reading the reviews it is quite obvious that often they do not refer to the specific item of interest at all.
    Last edited by Dave2002; 12-06-20, 20:15.
  • Triforium
    Full Member
    • Nov 2010
    • 147

    #2
    At least you take the time to write honest reviews. There are so many questionable reviews that I have taken to using fakespot.com. It evaluates the authenticity of the reviews.

    Comment

    • johnb
      Full Member
      • Mar 2007
      • 2903

      #3
      There are some products on Amazon where the seller offers an Amazon voucher if you write a favourable review.

      Comment

      • Dave2002
        Full Member
        • Dec 2010
        • 18035

        #4
        Originally posted by Boilk
        Dave2002: To see a list of all your Amazon reviews, imediately beneath Amazon's black masthead there is the white Your Amazon.co.uk toolbar. Along that, click on Your Public Profile to see your reviews, starting with the latest.

        I tend to leave reviews when displeased with some aspect of a purchase as a warning to others, as I much appreciate others flagging up issues. I confess to once having left a review after the seller offered me a free repeat product (Vitamin capsules) if I reviewed my purchase. They didn't stipulate it had to be favourable - but I had no issues anyway and got a free 2nd supply of something I would have repurchased anyway!

        What annoys me is people on Amazon giving a 5-star "review" that goes along the lines of: "Have not yet had time to use the product but it arrived very quickly" or a 1-star "review" that says "Product arrived in broken packaging" - which is likely the fault of the courier firm.
        The Your Public Profile link is not showing up for me. Is it user or browser or OS dependent?

        I agree about the other ways that these reviews are being "misused" - such as a seller offering discounts, or even threatening something if a good review isn't forthcoming.

        Comment

        • Dave2002
          Full Member
          • Dec 2010
          • 18035

          #5
          Originally posted by Boilk
          Turns out it's sub-toolbar of the main toolbar. On main black toolbar try clicking on Dave's Amazon (between Best Sellers and Links) and then a white toolbar should appear below, which includes Your Public Profile.
          Thanks. It is well hidden - I'm not sure that it was always thus.

          Comment

          Working...
          X