Originally posted by eighthobstruction
View Post
Petrol and Diesel Cars 2035
Collapse
X
-
Originally posted by ardcarp View PostWhilst I'm all in favour of harnessing wave-power (which is unfortunately variable to some extent depending of the wind and weather) I think that in a small country such as ours, we should think twice before damming up the Severn/Bristol Channel*. It would have devastating consequences for wildlife and biodiversity. Things are slightly different in the very long and mountainous country of Norway where 'hydroelectric' has worked for decades with minimal disturbance to ecosystems.
* Submerged tidal turbines might work though.
Wave power is not quite the same as tidal power - though the two are related. Where there's a big tidal range, tidal power should be rather reliable. Also, I think possibly that the generation from tidal is more efficient than from waves. Submerged turbines do work, though whether they can generate enough electricity I don't know. Large scale systems may block river flows, which would probably not be good.
Other options for improving conditions, such as a human cull, would be a lot less popular, but could reduce CO2 emissions considerably, and might actually improve long term survivability of the human race. I'm not volunteering myself - though I'll most likely be gone in a decade or two.
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by ardcarp View PostPresumably some clever people in government have thought out all the implications of 'stopping the sale' of petrol and diesel cars in 2035.
Loads of questions abound.
Will manufacturers carry on making them until December 31st 2034?
Will there be a frantic buying spree from petrol-heads as the deadline approaches?
If you buy a car abroad will you be able to drive it in the UK?
What will happen to all the millions of cars that will come up for scrappage?
Will there be enough charging stations?
Will people who live in very rural areas still be able to get around?
Will the ban apply to commercial vehicles?
Ditto public transport vehicles, eg buses and minibuses?
For how long after the deadline will you be able to carry on driving your petrol/diesel car?
Will the 'selling' ban apply to 2nd-hand cars?
I'm as green as can be...but I just foresee problems. Any thoughts?
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by ardcarp View PostPresumably some clever people in government have thought out all the implications of 'stopping the sale' of petrol and diesel cars in 2035.
Loads of questions abound.
Will manufacturers carry on making them until December 31st 2034?
Will there be a frantic buying spree from petrol-heads as the deadline approaches?
If you buy a car abroad will you be able to drive it in the UK?
What will happen to all the millions of cars that will come up for scrappage?
Will there be enough charging stations?
Will people who live in very rural areas still be able to get around?
Will the ban apply to commercial vehicles?
Ditto public transport vehicles, eg buses and minibuses?
For how long after the deadline will you be able to carry on driving your petrol/diesel car?
Will the 'selling' ban apply to 2nd-hand cars?
I'm as green as can be...but I just foresee problems. Any thoughts?
Comment
-
-
In much the same way as drivers were encouraged to switch to unleaded (not lead free-there's difference!) petrol in the 1980s by a financial incentive, electric cars need the same to encourage buyers. How about 0% VAT on electric cars? Once the number of cars goes over a critical number or percentage, forecourts previously dispensing petrol & diesel will become charging points. This change is starting, albeit slowly, but it IS changing... I'm seriously looking at an electric Vauxhall Corsa (Corsa E) for my wife, to replace her Skoda Fabia, which has 100,000 miles on the clock. She does 2-3K miles per annum and it's mostly urban runs. If you're used to petrol cars an electric one does seem weird to begin with, but a test drive impressed me!Major Denis Bloodnok, Indian Army (RTD) Coward and Bar, currently residing in Barnet, Hertfordshire!
Comment
-
-
I'm an ideal candidate for an electric car, and in my previous house the combination of driveway and E7 tariff would also have been ideal but the finances completely ruled it out - upfront cost plus battery leasing(problematic on 2nd hand vehicles) way too much. Now my driving is so limited distance-wise and the frequency of short trips has increased due to health issues it would be even more useful, but the cost is still way out of reach(max budget for replacing my car 3 years ago was £2000) and now I've moved house I wouldn't be able to charge at home as no driveway. I'm also not sure about the availability of local maintenance facilities.
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by ardcarp View PostHow does the price compare with an equivalent petrol car?
There has been an incentive "grant" which I think was £3.5k, but perhaps that's about to be taken away - from March. I'm not sure. If so, will dealers pass on the effective price rise to customers, or not? I suspect that the incentive hasn't been big enough, and pulling it off soon before too many people take these up does not seem sensible.
The reduction in fuel costs if electricity is obtained cheaply is significant, but it is not so signicant as to make up for the price differential between regular fossil fuel cars and the new electric ones which don't burn any - or at least not directly. Plug-in hybrid cars may be the best option for city dwellers, though most only have a range of about 30 miles before they need to switch to liquid fuels. This is based on the need to operate cleanly in urban environments, and a manageable cycle of operational patterns, though it does assume that drivers will actually operate the cars in electric mode where they can. One survey suggested that many drivers actually just left these permanently in petrol (diesel) mode (perhaps out of ignorance ..), in which case they are actually worse than the equivalent petrol or diesel cars. Regular hybrid cars (which Toyota and Lexus now seem to be touting as "self charging hybrids") may be good for more general motoring, as although they will be more polluting than pure electric cars, or plug-in hybrids operating in electric mode, they will often have an enhanced efficiency compared with a pure petrol or diesel car. Thus although they will still emit CO2, they will emit proportionately less for any given distance. They will however, be less clean than either pure electric or plug-in hybrids in city environments. For those cars, any pollution may be at the electricity generating stations - well out of sight, though hopefully in the very long term the generating stations will also be clean.
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by oddoneout View PostI'm an ideal candidate for an electric car, and in my previous house the combination of driveway and E7 tariff would also have been ideal but the finances completely ruled it out - upfront cost plus battery leasing(problematic on 2nd hand vehicles) way too much. Now my driving is so limited distance-wise and the frequency of short trips has increased due to health issues it would be even more useful, but the cost is still way out of reach(max budget for replacing my car 3 years ago was £2000) and now I've moved house I wouldn't be able to charge at home as no driveway. I'm also not sure about the availability of local maintenance facilities.
The cheapest electric cars seem to be above £20k, which is at the low end for petrol and diesel cars, but it is still possible to get some small petrol and/or diesel cars for not much more than £10k, and there is also a second hand market.
There is a second hand market for electric cars too, but the problem with that is that batteries have improved a lot over the last few years, so second hand electric cars currently have a really poor range due to their batteries. Those cars had poor range due to the batteries when they were new, and after a few years that has diminished furthter. Eventually batteries will be good enough that used cars may be a viable proposition, but I wouldn't recommend them just now. Sometimes there are bargains and opportunities, but not often. I did meet one person who had bought an electric car which had been misused, leading to some severe electrical failure. As a result he got it very cheaply - presumably it would otherwise have been scrapped. However, as he was an electrical engineer and knowledgeable, he was able to repair it and bring it back up to near full specification for very little cost and not too much effort. Very few people would be able to do that.
About charging electric cars - in some areas local councils will provide a charging point nearby , or arrange for charging points at places of work, as an incentive for people to take up these vehicles. In the worst cases it is still possible, though not terribly desirable, to run an extension cable out to the road. That would enable a car to charge up sufficiently so that the driver could then take it to a nearby charging point. The charge would be very slow, though - but running the battery down is similar to running out of petrol - something most drivers will try to avoid.Last edited by Dave2002; 07-02-20, 00:09.
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by Dave2002 View PostDo you really mean £2000? That normally only gets a fairly old second hand car - though I've had a number of those, and some very cheap ones over many years.
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by oddoneout View PostYup. Old secondhand is all I can afford. I got lucky as a colleague was selling her car, a 2008 Nissan Micra and when I said I would like it she reduced the price so I paid £1400. It was in very good condition,and regularly serviced. If I didn't need it to get to work I probably wouldn't have one at all.
Keeping old things working is much more preferable than the constant buying and making of new ones
I'm seriously thinking of getting an old diesel Land Rover and running it on vegetable oil, which @ £1.00 per litre is a good option.
Comment
-
Comment