How wide or narrow is your musical taste?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Mary Chambers
    Full Member
    • Nov 2010
    • 1963

    #16
    I suppose people would call my tastes fairly narrow, because they are more or less confined to 'classical' music, though eclectic within that. I've always tended to put this down to my background and generation, but if Salymap listened to John Peel then I am obviously wrong! I was a child in the 40s, a teenager in the 50s. Until I was perhaps fourteen I heard very little 'popular' music. There was virtually none at home or school. I vaguely knew some songs from Disney films like Snow White and The Wizard of Oz (though I was never taken to the films) and my grandfather had some Paul Robeson records. Everything else was 'classical' or sometimes folk song. My father liked French popular music (Edith Piaf, Jean Sablon), so I suppose I knew some of that.

    In my teenage years I was aware that some people at school listened to Radio Luxembourg, but I never did. I quite liked Harry Belafonte, but Bill Haley I found absurd (his followers still more so) and Elvis Presley repelled me - still does. I don't think I felt snobbish about pop and rock (well, perhaps a bit - my parents certainly did), but I regarded them as a separate world that simply didn't concern me. My friends shared my tastes, and I didn't feel at all left out.

    By the 60s I was so immersed in the classical world, particularly singing, that the pop scene largely passed me by. I was aware of the Beatles, of course, but pretty much unaffected by them - though I did buy the EP of Penny Lane/Strawberry Fields, because I knew the places.

    It still surprises me that anyone can listen to Elvis Presley and Schubert lieder - if anyone does. I don't really understand why Presley doesn't hurt their ears. I also think that 'wide tastes', fashionable at the moment, can just indicate lack of judgement sometimes. It's not always a virtue. (And talking of hurting ears, my brother played in a jazz band that sometimes rehearsed at our house, so I didn't like jazz either!)

    There is so much 'classical' music - I still have many gaps in my knowledge of it although I've been listening and performing it for very many years. I simply don't have time for everything!

    EDIT: I should add that by 'folk song' I don't mean the real thing, which I hadn't experienced. I mean folk songs as sung at school from the National Songbook, or on the radio by Peter Pears or Kathleen Ferrier.
    Last edited by Mary Chambers; 17-06-11, 14:11.

    Comment

    • salymap
      Late member
      • Nov 2010
      • 5969

      #17
      I worked for a time with Tom Robinson who more or less took over from John Peel. Also a cousin in law visited Peel at Peel' s home in Suffolk [I think], so thought I would give it a go. I didn't understand all or most of what he played but his broad knowledge of people and all sorts of music was impressive and in my view irreplaceable.

      Morning Mary, by the way

      Comment

      • Paul Sherratt

        #18
        Tom Robinson is a good man. His ears are wide open. I presume that's why the bbc choose to allow him to broadcast in the early hours of the morning. BBC Radio 1's controller did the same with John Peel. Nice people those managers.

        Comment

        • Paul Sherratt

          #19
          My music taste ?
          Wide and shallow

          Comment

          • Roehre

            #20
            My musical taste?
            Very narrow, only "classical" between the 12th and the 21st centuries, some jazz (especially bebop), and that's it I'm afraid

            Comment

            • Mandryka

              #21
              Originally posted by Mary Chambers View Post
              I suppose people would call my tastes fairly narrow, because they are more or less confined to 'classical' music, though eclectic within that. I've always tended to put this down to my background and generation, but if Salymap listened to John Peel then I am obviously wrong! I was a child in the 40s, a teenager in the 50s. Until I was perhaps fourteen I heard very little 'popular' music. There was virtually none at home or school. I vaguely knew some songs from Disney films like Snow White and The Wizard of Oz (though I was never taken to the films) and my grandfather had some Paul Robeson records. Everything else was 'classical' or sometimes folk song. My father liked French popular music (Edith Piaf, Jean Sablon), so I suppose I knew some of that.

              In my teenage years I was aware that some people at school listened to Radio Luxembourg, but I never did. I quite liked Harry Belafonte, but Bill Haley I found absurd (his followers still more so) and Elvis Presley repelled me - still does. I don't think I felt snobbish about pop and rock (well, perhaps a bit - my parents certainly did), but I regarded them as a separate world that simply didn't concern me. My friends shared my tastes, and I didn't feel at all left out.

              By the 60s I was so immersed in the classical world, particularly singing, that the pop scene largely passed me by. I was aware of the Beatles, of course, but pretty much unaffected by them - though I did buy the EP of Penny Lane/Strawberry Fields, because I knew the places.

              It still surprises me that anyone can listen to Elvis Presley and Schubert lieder - if anyone does. I don't really understand why Presley doesn't hurt their ears. I also think that 'wide tastes', fashionable at the moment, can just indicate lack of judgement sometimes. It's not always a virtue. (And talking of hurting ears, my brother played in a jazz band that sometimes rehearsed at our house, so I didn't like jazz either!)

              There is so much 'classical' music - I still have many gaps in my knowledge of it although I've been listening and performing it for very many years. I simply don't have time for everything!

              EDIT: I should add that by 'folk song' I don't mean the real thing, which I hadn't experienced. I mean folks songs as sung at school from the National Songbook, or on the radio by Peter Pears or Kathleen Ferrier.

              Elvis Presley or Schubert lieder - I don't care much for either. But you may be shocked to learn that Elvis has been well and truly trounced in the decibel stakes.

              John Peel.....he had an engaging manner and was a great broadcaster, but I always found 90% of his programme unlistenable; and I was not the only one...I once knew someone who'd tape his spoken intros but leave out the music.

              Comment

              • french frank
                Administrator/Moderator
                • Feb 2007
                • 30652

                #22
                Originally posted by Paul Sherratt View Post
                My music taste ?
                Wide and shallow
                As it should be, Pavel. People whose taste is wide and deep are missing out on many other things
                It isn't given us to know those rare moments when people are wide open and the lightest touch can wither or heal. A moment too late and we can never reach them any more in this world.

                Comment

                • 3rd Viennese School

                  #23
                  My tastes range from Mahler, Prokofiev and right through to Shoshtakovich.

                  3VS

                  Comment

                  • teamsaint
                    Full Member
                    • Nov 2010
                    • 25250

                    #24
                    Originally posted by Paul Sherratt View Post
                    Tom Robinson is a good man. His ears are wide open. I presume that's why the bbc choose to allow him to broadcast in the early hours of the morning. BBC Radio 1's controller did the same with John Peel. Nice people those managers.
                    one thing John Peel really taught you was how to listen to and appreciate anything that came your way. You would turn on at 10 PM not really knowing what would be on, and invariably be treated to something a little out of you comfort zone that someone else was enthusing about.He was a good teacher, and like rob cowan had an enviable depth of knowledge that you could draw from.
                    I will not be pushed, filed, stamped, indexed, briefed, debriefed or numbered. My life is my own.

                    I am not a number, I am a free man.

                    Comment

                    • salymap
                      Late member
                      • Nov 2010
                      • 5969

                      #25
                      Originally posted by teamsaint View Post
                      one thing John Peel really taught you was how to listen to and appreciate anything that came your way. You would turn on at 10 PM not really knowing what would be on, and invariably be treated to something a little out of you comfort zone that someone else was enthusing about.He was a good teacher, and like rob cowan had an enviable depth of knowledge that you could draw from.
                      I couldn't agree more about John Peel, Tom Robinson and Rob Cowan. Great knowledge, worn lightly.

                      Comment

                      • Paul Sherratt

                        #26
                        Elegantly put, salymap.

                        Comment

                        • Suffolkcoastal
                          Full Member
                          • Nov 2010
                          • 3297

                          #27
                          My musical taste is almost exclusively Classical (in the wider term), and my enormous collection of recorded music spans music from the 13th Century to the 21st, there aren't many composers whose music I dislike so I would say my tastes within 'classical' music are very broad indeed. I don't mind some musicals, I admire Stephen Sondheim and some early 80's pop music, I was a fan of Howard Jones and still find some of his songs interesting.

                          Comment

                          • MrGongGong
                            Full Member
                            • Nov 2010
                            • 18357

                            #28
                            Thinking about this some more
                            I think that one sometimes needs to separate knowledge from taste
                            One of the problems some of us have in music education is that music is often only seen in terms of taste
                            whether you like it or not doesn't always mean that it's not worthy of serious consideration
                            this applies across many musical genres

                            Comment

                            • vinteuil
                              Full Member
                              • Nov 2010
                              • 13065

                              #29
                              these questions often elicit various forms of apparent superiority - "mine's bigger than yours" - "mine's more refined than yours" - "mine's more obscure than yours".

                              I very much liked Fr Fr's comments above - that she has moved on from some kinds of music to others, and doesn't need to cling...

                              Actually my predominant tastes haven't changed all that much in the last fifty years: I have never enjoyed 'light' or 'popular' music; always get most out of 16th, 17th, 18th century music; have slowly come to appreciate some later 19th century music; dislike overly romantic 'emotional' stuff that wears its heart on its sleeve; usually prefer smaller intimate forces to larger bombastic styles; can't abide sentimentalities, cowpats, music-theatre...
                              Last edited by vinteuil; 17-06-11, 15:29. Reason: punctuation

                              Comment

                              • gurnemanz
                                Full Member
                                • Nov 2010
                                • 7445

                                #30
                                CD stats: classical 80%, rock 10%, jazz 6%, folk 2%, misc 2%

                                When I was at school we listened only to rock and pop via Radio Luxembourg and the pirates (Kenny Everett was our cult hero). I'm still very fond of the Sixties pop which coincided with my adolescence and have acquired various bulky CD compilations just for old times' sake. Auntie BBC provided almost nothing in the pop field until Radio One came along in 1967, by which time I was more interested in classical music. I only really ever listened to John Peel's late night show on that station.

                                Since then I have maintained an interest in just a few singers who I really like and whose development I have followed closely over the decades - Dylan, Joni Mitchell, Emmylou Harris, Richard Thompson, Tom Waits and more recently the fabulous Lucinda Williams, who a friend put me on to. Tom Waits is the only one of those I have not seen live.

                                My daughter, aged 29, often plays me rock CDs which she thinks I will like and I usually do.

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X