If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.
Left the same jazz CDs in the car for over a week and plumped for something really different - a collection of Saint-Saens. It does include the famous Carnival of the animals but the largest chunk of the disc is his symphony which features the organ. I quite like the music although clearly not in the same league as most other French composers (Debussy, Faure, Ravel, Poulenc, Messaien, etc) it is interesting enough to enjoy. I didn't realise that he was such a reactionary against the musical changes of the late 19th / early 20th century.
Left the same jazz CDs in the car for over a week and plumped for something really different - a collection of Saint-Saens. It does include the famous Carnival of the animals but the largest chunk of the disc is his symphony which features the organ. I quite like the music although clearly not in the same league as most other French composers (Debussy, Faure, Ravel, Poulenc, Messaien, etc) it is interesting enough to enjoy. I didn't realise that he was such a reactionary against the musical changes of the late 19th / early 20th century.
Can't agree! Saint-Saens's music, in my view, is on the same level as those others you mention especially the Symphony No. 3 'Organ' which is a masterpiece. Although not progressive for its time, rather backward looking, Saint-Saens's music away from the dynamic of the time it matters not a jot when we hear it now.
It is unfortunate that he has gone from flavour of the month in the late 1980s to someone who is seriously under-valued and one of the most original composers in jazz. This album is excellent.
Can't agree! Saint-Saens's music, in my view, is on the same level as those others you mention especially the Symphony No. 3 'Organ' which is a masterpiece. Although not progressive for its time, rather backward looking, Saint-Saens's music away from the dynamic of the time it matters not a jot when we hear it now.
Anyway I apologise as this is a Jazz thread.
Stanford
I have been checking out some of his chamber work on line such as a Sonata for bassoon. It is ok but not great. I get the impression that he is someone like Milhaud insofar that there are some great pieces of music but also a lot of really average stuff. The Organ symphony is great but, as you say, he was a bit old-fashioned at the time and remained a staunch conservative. Couldn't see him digging you Blue Note collection !!
I must beg to differ. Saint-Saens's music is on different elevated level to Milhaud. But of course, it's all about personal taste.
Milhaud's writing is often said to be jazz influenced, which might appeal to you. How many Milhaud works can the average listener name? I can name one but I'm not still sure of its correct spelling never mind its pronunciation.
Not sure what my Blue Note collection has to do with anything! You aren't a wind-up merchant are you?
Comment