Choral discords

[Simon]

I'll spare you the embarrassment.

Oh no, please don't. That would be most unfair. I really must insist that, having been put on the spot, you justify your attack on me. Or admit that you can't.

[orbis factor]

Oh no, please don't. That would be most unfair. I really must insist that, having been put on the spot, you justify your attack on me. Or admit that you can't.

Time to stop digging?

[pole_2_pole]

Where's the "disrespect", as you put it? Are you sure you understand what disrespect means?

Whatever.

[jean]

...the thread, started by me, was a very positive, friendly and reasonable one until GongGong appeared...

No it wasn't. Your provocative

...any independent musician...

had already appeared.

[MrGongGong]

Thanks Jean

My original comments on that discussion were very much about music and it's contexts. Sadly there are some who find the referring to church music in a wider context as somehow "off topic" and not "what we are supposed to be discussing" etc

Given that Simon has been (and with much fanfare trumpets and more drums that in Berlioz's Requiem ) ignoring me for the last year or so his comments seem a little odd but I guess he is now not doing this ?

It's a shame that potentially interesting (and sometimes heated) discussions are often derailed by one individual who really can't complain when people get a bit irked ........his

"a big boy did it and then ran away miss" argument is a bit limp imv

[french frank]

This probably isn't discussing anything worth continuing with and I've been asked to close the thread. Which I do without further comment.