Which conductor/performer/composer would you most like to have met?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Ruhevoll
    • Nov 2024

    Which conductor/performer/composer would you most like to have met?

    And what would you have asked them?

    A bit of Friday fun. It could also be applied to present day conductors/performers/composers.
  • Tevot
    Full Member
    • Nov 2010
    • 1011

    #2
    Mahler

    I'd ask him : " Why don't you lighten up ? "



    Best Wishes,

    Tevot

    Comment

    • Hornspieler
      Late Member
      • Sep 2012
      • 1847

      #3
      Originally posted by Ruhevoll View Post
      And what would you have asked them?

      A bit of Friday fun. It could also be applied to present day conductors/performers/composers.
      It will always be one of my regrets that I never had the opportunity to play for Celibidache, Eduard van Beinum, Pierre Monteux or Ernst Ansermet.

      With conductors of that stature, you don't ask them anything but you pay close attention to what they have to say to you.

      HS

      Comment

      • Ruhevoll

        #4
        Originally posted by Hornspieler View Post
        It will always be one of my regrets that I never had the opportunity to play for Celibidache, Eduard van Beinum, Pierre Monteux or Ernst Ansermet.

        With conductors of that stature, you don't ask them anything but you pay close attention to what they have to say to you.

        HS


        Celibidache is quite a recent discovery for me, but his unique approach to music is really interesting. I was listening to his Brahms (EMI) last night and, to quote one very nice Amazon review, he makes the music 'breathe'. Very different from the singing, lilting quality of Walter, but his approach certainly makes you hear new things in what can feel like overly familiar music at times. And his Bruckner has been a revelation.

        > You might find this interesting, HS: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SthKs40ClCY

        Comment

        • Zucchini
          Guest
          • Nov 2010
          • 917

          #5
          Daniel Barenboim - it would be a great experience but I'd be pretty nervous of his massive intellect

          or Helene Grimaud - we could talk about wolves, the influence of synesthesia on her playing and how lovely she looks
          Last edited by Zucchini; 20-09-13, 20:33.

          Comment

          • Ferretfancy
            Full Member
            • Nov 2010
            • 3487

            #6
            Many years ago, I sat over a cup of coffee at the BBC's Maida Vale studios having a very nice chat with the young David Zinman. The trouble is, I can't remember a word, and that's the problem. What would you ask Mozart, for example ?

            Comment

            • Hornspieler
              Late Member
              • Sep 2012
              • 1847

              #7
              Originally posted by Ruhevoll View Post


              Celibidache is quite a recent discovery for me, but his unique approach to music is really interesting. I was listening to his Brahms (EMI) last night and, to quote one very nice Amazon review, he makes the music 'breathe'. Very different from the singing, lilting quality of Walter, but his approach certainly makes you hear new things in what can feel like overly familiar music at times. And his Bruckner has been a revelation.

              > You might find this interesting, HS: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SthKs40ClCY
              Thanks for the link, Ruhevoll. For Silvestri, his fellow Rumanian was a rival, but I believe that the influence of Georges Enescu was an important link between the two conductors and influenced their interpretaion of, particularly, Eastern European late 19th century music.

              So I would have loved to see and play for Celibidache, who's reputation and success preceded that of Silvestri in our own country.

              HS

              Comment

              • Dave2002
                Full Member
                • Dec 2010
                • 18021

                #8
                i once met one of my heroes Stephen Kovacevich at a party. Unfortunately I didn't know who he was as our hostess had only introduced him as Steve, though she thought I might be interested in meeting him and would know him. We got round to asking what we each did, and he replied something along the lines of "I play the piano, a bit". A string of questions and answers followed ... "What kind of music do you play and/or like?", "where do you play?", and the high spot might have been " Can you make a living out of that?" Eventually we talked about American football, which he seemed to like.

                I was not pleased afterwards when I realised whom I'd been talking to. If you're out there Stephen I hope you nevertheless had fun with that. I still like your playing a lot.

                Comment

                • amateur51

                  #9
                  Originally posted by Hornspieler View Post
                  Thanks for the link, Ruhevoll. For Silvestri, his fellow Rumanian was a rival, but I believe that the influence of Georges Enescu was an important link between the two conductors and influenced their interpretaion of, particularly, Eastern European late 19th century music.

                  So I would have loved to see and play for Celibidache, who's reputation and success preceded that of Silvestri in our own country.

                  HS
                  Celibache conducts Enescu 'live'

                  Celibidache in Bucharest: (1978)G.Enescu: Rapsodia Română n°1 in La mag."G.Enescu" Philharmonic OrchestraSergiu Celibidache, cond.rec. in Ateneul Roman 1978

                  Comment

                  • EdgeleyRob
                    Guest
                    • Nov 2010
                    • 12180

                    #10
                    Felix Mendelssohn and Ralph Vaughan Williams,"thank you for keeping me sane".

                    Charles Valentin Alkan, "You don't fancy playing your Trois Etudes de Bravoure Op. 16 for me do you ?".

                    Helene Grimaud,"Can you teach me to play the piano from scratch please ?".

                    Adrian Boult and Richard Hickox, "Thanks".

                    Deborah Harry,"What are you doing later ?".

                    Comment

                    • teamsaint
                      Full Member
                      • Nov 2010
                      • 25210

                      #11
                      Originally posted by EdgeleyRob View Post
                      Felix Mendelssohn and Ralph Vaughan Williams,"thank you for keeping me sane".

                      Charles Valentin Alkan, "You don't fancy playing your Trois Etudes de Bravoure Op. 16 for me do you ?".

                      Helene Grimaud,"Can you teach me to play the piano from scratch please ?".


                      Adrian Boult and Richard Hickox, "Thanks".

                      Deborah Harry,"What are you doing later ?".



                      Better chat up line than I would manage, ER !!

                      I would ask

                      Brahms: " Which cupboard is all the abandonned material in?"

                      Robert Palmer: " How did you stay cool while doing uncool things, and sometimes making uncool music". Great singer IMO, and a cool guy.
                      I will not be pushed, filed, stamped, indexed, briefed, debriefed or numbered. My life is my own.

                      I am not a number, I am a free man.

                      Comment

                      • Serial_Apologist
                        Full Member
                        • Dec 2010
                        • 37691

                        #12
                        Originally posted by teamsaint View Post
                        [/B]


                        Robert Palmer: " How did you stay cool while doing uncool things, and sometimes making uncool music". Great singer IMO, and a cool guy.
                        For a moment there I got confused with Robert Plant!!!

                        I would have liked to ask Sun Ra if he really believed he was born on Saturn.

                        If you check the A-Z for London you'ss notice a street turning off Denmark Hill in south London called Sunray Avenue. When I first visited the district thinking of moving here, someone had stuck something over the "y" on the street sign, and I took this as a good omen in making my decision.

                        Comment

                        • teamsaint
                          Full Member
                          • Nov 2010
                          • 25210

                          #13
                          Originally posted by Serial_Apologist View Post
                          For a moment there I got confused with Robert Plant!!!

                          I would have liked to ask Sun Ra if he really believed he was born on Saturn.

                          If you check the A-Z for London you'ss notice a street turning off Denmark Hill in south London called Sunray Avenue. When I first visited the district thinking of moving here, someone had stuck something over the "y" on the street sign, and I took this as a good omen in making my decision.
                          Someone was telling you something., S_A.

                          Plant, Palmer. Just good old Rock n Rollers.
                          I miss Robert Palmer, Dunno why. Just seemed like one of the good guys. Despite the sexist videos n all. I expect he regretted them, really.
                          I will not be pushed, filed, stamped, indexed, briefed, debriefed or numbered. My life is my own.

                          I am not a number, I am a free man.

                          Comment

                          • amateur51

                            #14
                            I'm reminded of the occasion when a newspaper sent along a reporter to interview the pianist Shura Cherkassky in his tiny flat in The White House, an hotel at the top of Great Portland Street, London.

                            He plied the diminutive maestro with one or two of his questions, all of which Shura had heard many times before.

                            Shura finally lost patience and said

                            "Ah, we don't want to talk about this stuff, it's boring. Now, let me show you my suits"


                            SHURA CHERKASSKY BRINGING ELEGANT VIRTUOSITY AND OLD WORLD CHARM TO SHULZ-EVLER'S DAZZLING CONCERT ARABESQUES ON STRAUSS'S 'BLUE DANUBE WALTZ.' HIS ENCORE -...


                            Comment

                            • Serial_Apologist
                              Full Member
                              • Dec 2010
                              • 37691

                              #15
                              Originally posted by amateur51 View Post
                              I'm reminded of the occasion when a newspaper sent along a reporter to interview the pianist Shura Cherkassky in his tiny flat in The White House, an hotel at the top of Great Portland Street, London.

                              He plied the diminutive maestro with one or two of his questions, all of which Shura had heard many times before.

                              Shura finally lost patience and said

                              "Ah, we don't want to talk about this stuff, it's boring. Now, let me show you my suits"


                              SHURA CHERKASSKY BRINGING ELEGANT VIRTUOSITY AND OLD WORLD CHARM TO SHULZ-EVLER'S DAZZLING CONCERT ARABESQUES ON STRAUSS'S 'BLUE DANUBE WALTZ.' HIS ENCORE -...


                              I was once detailed to interview a well-known American singer known as a difficult character for an avant garde music journal. I arrived at the appointed place heavily dosed on painkillers for a slipped disc, feeling floaty instead of my usual nervous. She entered the room sporting dark glasses more impenetrable than Ray Charles's and proceeded to stall on all my pre-prepared questions. After half an hour I suddenly realised in my state that I had omitted to press "record", and found myself overflowing with apologies, "Oh never mind, never mind!" she exclaimed, throwing aside her shades, "You look in such pain, and maybe I wasn't supposed to say all that stuff!" From that point on the interview went superbly!

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X