The 2020 Survey of Classical Music on Radio 3

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Suffolkcoastal
    Full Member
    • Nov 2010
    • 3290

    The 2020 Survey of Classical Music on Radio 3

    Here’s my 2020 Survey of Classical Music on Radio 3, the 12th I’ve undertaken. As with everything else, Covid has had a considerable impact on the live concerts with a higher proportion of songs, chamber & piano pieces. The huge unprecedented increase in non-classical works being played in the usual classical music slots noted in 2019 continued unabated, increasing by a further 29% and has now trebled from 10 years ago & accounts for around 10% of the chunks/pieces in classical programmes! The published playlists continue to remain a nightmare with many instances of duplications within & between programmes, mis-attributations.
    Anniversary composers were of course dominated by Beethoven. The opportunity for the other anniversary composers such as Reicha & Bruch, was limited in the extreme, in fact Bruch has less chunks/pieces broadcast than he did in 2019! There’s the continuing promotion of women composers, particularly certain favoured ones. There are the usual favoured composers whilst many other notable composers such as Honegger, Holmboe, Tippett, Berwald, K A Hartmann, Henze, E Carter, continued to be generally poorly represented. Many of R3 favourite warhorses were broadcast in record (since 2009) numbers complete or in chunks including: Ravel’s G Major Concerto & Alborado del Gracioso, Appalachian Spring, The Planets (accounts for nearly 40% of Holst broadcasts), Concierto de Aranjuez (almost half the Rodrigo broadcast), the ‘American’ Quartet, Peter Grimes Sea Interludes.
    The opportunity to explore R3s huge archive of broadcasts created by the lack of many live concerts was exceptionally disappointing. Instead playlist programmes continue to dominate. Overall, rather a depressing year.
    As usual, a list of all composers with 50 or more pieces/chunks broadcast is in the thread below. If there are any composers not in this category that you would like to know the figures for, please let me know.
    The *against a composer indicates the highest number of pieces/chunks by that composer since I began my survey in 2009, whilst the # indicates the lowest number since 2009.
    The R3 Symphony survey will follow shortly.
  • Suffolkcoastal
    Full Member
    • Nov 2010
    • 3290

    #2
    1 beethoven 1922*
    2 bach j s 1845*
    3 mozart w a 1462
    4 schubert 1264
    5 brahms 786
    6 handel 779
    7 haydn f j 763
    8 chopin 655
    9 debussy 648
    10 dvorak 629*
    11 tchaikovsky p i 536
    12 vivaldi 517
    13 mendelssohn felix 505
    14 ravel 501
    15 schumann r 474
    16 strauss r 451
    17 rachmaninov 424*
    18 britten 402
    19 sibelius 369
    20 purcell h 357
    21 grieg 351
    22 elgar 341
    23 vaughan williams 339
    24 shostakovich 331
    25 liszt 323
    26 saint-saens 292
    27 prokofiev s 266
    28 stravinsky 240
    29 faure 235
    29 poulenc 235
    30 telemann 234
    31 mahler g 222
    32 rossini 210
    33 wagner r 208
    34 monteverdi 200
    35 scarlatti d 185
    35 verdi 185#
    36 byrd 182
    37 holst g 181*
    38 gershwin 176
    39 berlioz 175
    40 bartok 174
    40 nielsen c 174
    41 dowland 169
    42 janacek 165
    43 rameau 160
    44 bach c p e 154
    45 copland 153
    46 part 150
    47 bruckner 139*
    48 puccini 133
    49 schumann c 132
    49 strauss j ii 132
    50 korngold 129*
    51 weber c m von 124
    52 gesualdo 121*
    52 glass p 121*
    52 walton 121
    53 bernstein l 112
    54 rimsky korsakov 111
    55 respighi 110
    56 bizet 107
    57 arnold m 101
    58 price florence 100*
    59 satie 98
    60 finzi 97*
    60 piazzolla 97
    60 smetana 97
    61 grainger p 96
    62 tallis 95
    63 mendelssohn fanny 92*
    63 sullivan 92
    64 still w g 89*
    65 scriabin 88
    66 franck c 87
    67 beach 85
    68 macmillan j 84
    69 couperin f 82
    69 kodaly 82
    69 mussorgsky 82
    69 schoenberg 82
    70 bruch 81
    70 reich 81
    71 adams j 78
    71 glazunov 78
    71 messiaen 78
    72 stanford 77
    73 falla 75
    73 kreisler f 75
    73 ligeti g 75
    73 villa lobos 75
    74 barber s 72
    74 bridge 72
    75 bingen hildegard of 71*
    75 gibbons o 71
    76 albeniz 70
    76 borodin 70
    77 coleridge-taylor s 68*
    77 corelli 68
    78 delius 67
    78 pejacevic 67*
    78 williams j 67
    79 howells 66
    79 szymanowski 66*
    80 gabrieli g 65
    80 martinu 65
    81 hahn r 64*
    82 farrenc l 63*
    82 wallen e 63*
    83 tippett 62
    84 richter m 60*
    84 suk 60
    85 glinka 59
    86 chabrier 58
    86 johnson james 58*
    86 palestrina 58#
    87 strozzi b 57
    87 wolf h 57
    88 ives c 56
    88 rodrigo 56*
    89 delibes 54
    89 gluck 54
    89 khachaturian 54
    89 stenhammar 54*
    90 boccherini 53
    90 enescu 53
    90 shaw caroline 53*
    90 tavener 53
    90 weill 53
    91 bacewicz 50
    91 biber 50
    91 buxtehude 50
    91 josquin 50
    91 pachelbel 50
    91 paganini 50#

    Comment

    • french frank
      Administrator/Moderator
      • Feb 2007
      • 30285

      #3
      Oh, joy! I'd just been pressed to discover whether we could expect a version this year, Suffy. Thank you so much!
      It isn't given us to know those rare moments when people are wide open and the lightest touch can wither or heal. A moment too late and we can never reach them any more in this world.

      Comment

      • antongould
        Full Member
        • Nov 2010
        • 8782

        #4
        Originally posted by french frank View Post
        Oh, joy! I'd just been pressed to discover whether we could expect a version this year, Suffy. Thank you so much!
        Excellent indeed suffy ....... from Andrew’s wonderful database we have extracted all the individual pieces that make up these summations .... if anyone has any detailed questions let me know and I will try to answer them - the vagaries of the playlists that Suffy mentions notwithstanding ....

        Comment

        • Ein Heldenleben
          Full Member
          • Apr 2014
          • 6779

          #5
          Palestrina ( of the greatest figures in the history of western music ) played less than Kreisler ( a salon composer ) ...what a weird world. And Buxtehude, Josquin and Pachelbel than Philip Glass.
          Mmm...I suppose they are composers out of tune with the times but they seem very underplayed ..

          Comment

          • Rolmill
            Full Member
            • Nov 2010
            • 634

            #6
            Great list, thanks sfc.

            Good to see 11 (on a quick count) female composers in the list, which is probably the most ever?

            I echo Heldenleben's disappointment at the comparatively poor showing of Palestrina - his lowest ever total (one of only three in this category) - and also note the absence of Lassus and Victoria. All played less often than Kreisler, Hahn and Max Richter...

            Comment

            • DracoM
              Host
              • Mar 2007
              • 12971

              #7

              One of the reasons I despaired of that list.

              Comment

              • hmvman
                Full Member
                • Mar 2007
                • 1099

                #8
                Thank you very much, suffolkcoastal, for all your work on this list. Interesting, if sometimes depressing, reading.

                Comment

                • french frank
                  Administrator/Moderator
                  • Feb 2007
                  • 30285

                  #9
                  Originally posted by Rolmill View Post
                  Good to see 11 (on a quick count) female composers in the list, which is probably the most ever?
                  I made it 11 - though mostly the new 'regulars'. Have they given up on making more discoveries? I don't absolutely begrudge Gershwin a place but given the small amount of 'classical' music he wrote, he does seem to occupy an unmerited position compared with some of the great names that just squeeze in at the very bottom. But where would we be without Walking the Dog, Variations on I Got Rhythm, Girl Crazy etc to cheer us up?
                  It isn't given us to know those rare moments when people are wide open and the lightest touch can wither or heal. A moment too late and we can never reach them any more in this world.

                  Comment

                  • Edgy 2
                    Guest
                    • Jan 2019
                    • 2035

                    #10
                    Many thanks as always sc for compiling this list,grim though it is
                    Last edited by Edgy 2; 02-01-21, 20:18.
                    “Music is the best means we have of digesting time." — Igor Stravinsky

                    Comment

                    • Ein Heldenleben
                      Full Member
                      • Apr 2014
                      • 6779

                      #11
                      Good to see so many Medieval / Renaissance choral music enthusiasts on the forum. Time for a repeat / updating of From Plainsong to Polyphony - a series that , appropriately enough , seemed to run for eternity.

                      Comment

                      • Leinster Lass
                        Banned
                        • Oct 2020
                        • 1099

                        #12
                        Originally posted by french frank View Post
                        I made it 11 - though mostly the new 'regulars'. Have they given up on making more discoveries? I don't absolutely begrudge Gershwin a place but given the small amount of 'classical' music he wrote, he does seem to occupy an unmerited position compared with some of the great names that just squeeze in at the very bottom. But where would we be without Walking the Dog, Variations on I Got Rhythm, Girl Crazy etc to cheer us up?
                        Presumably Rhapsody In Blue played a major part in Gershwin's success.

                        Comment

                        • french frank
                          Administrator/Moderator
                          • Feb 2007
                          • 30285

                          #13
                          Originally posted by Leinster Lass View Post
                          Presumably Rhapsody In Blue played a major part in Gershwin's success.
                          I assume you mean success as demonstrated by Suffy's list? Yes, for all I know, they could have played it 3 times every week to make the 176 broadcasts.
                          It isn't given us to know those rare moments when people are wide open and the lightest touch can wither or heal. A moment too late and we can never reach them any more in this world.

                          Comment

                          • Suffolkcoastal
                            Full Member
                            • Nov 2010
                            • 3290

                            #14
                            176 Chunks/pieces of Gershwin is a mid-range total for Gershwin, the lowest since I started the survey was 116 in 2009, the highest 248 in 2018. Rhapsody in Blue didn't feature that highly in 2020, more of a mix of his works across the board.

                            Regarding Palestrina, the highest figure since I started has been only 87 back in 2013, the average is 72 pieces/chunks per year.

                            Comment

                            • antongould
                              Full Member
                              • Nov 2010
                              • 8782

                              #15
                              Originally posted by french frank View Post
                              I assume you mean success as demonstrated by Suffy's list? Yes, for all I know, they could have played it 3 times every week to make the 176 broadcasts.
                              Not so - as Suffy says Rhapsody In Blue slipped down the table in 2020 with about 14 plays ..... Lord Stockton obviously sent out a WhatsApp message after discussions with you ff ...... anyone like to have a stab at the other 18 pieces played 14 or more times .... and spelt the same way on the Playlists .....

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X