Originally posted by teamsaint
View Post
What Classical Music Are You listening to Now? III
Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
This is a sticky topic.
X
X
-
Beethoven: Piano Concertos 4 and 3 (Mitsuko Uchida, BP, Simon Rattle - Blu-ray video with 48/16 surround audio). As ever with Uchida, I find the pianism somewhat mannered but also quite beautiful. By no means would I make this a library choice, but that does not mean it is not worth having and hearing. In her interview re. Beethoven and the concertos she emphasises the element of struggle, both in his life and his music. Not a word about the humour though, and I think that's a crucial aspect with she seems to have overlooked.
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by Richard Barrett View PostListening today for the first time to Riccardo Chailly's recordings of Schumann symphonies with the Gewandhausorchester, and beginning predictably enough with no.2. While people like JEG and Herreweghe have shown that Schumann's orchestration doesn't necessarily need reworking, if you're going to perform this music with a "modern" orchestra, with all the balance decisions that will involve, why not use Mahler's solutions? Especially when they're as well played as this. Does it actually sound like Mahler? Not at all, except maybe the dynamics at some moments. I look forward to another listen when I won't be so concerned with who and how, but just with the musical substance.
You should hear Ceccato though - he has a lovely, lyrical, completely different take on the Mahler arrangements...
Here's one I made earlier....(2017)...
Two excellent sets, but very different from each other…
I love the affectionately sweet, light take from Ceccato/Bergen SO. A special favourite, a pet set. Hidden treasure.
No idiosyncrasies of phrase or pace, lovely lift to the rhythms, that early-BIS mid hall spaciousness and fullness.
The 3rd is especially sunny and warm, almost a Rhine-sur-Med.
I sometimes find the Leipzig/Chailly climaxes a bit hefty for my taste but the whole thing is so brilliantly played and recorded it’s hard to carp…in fact the contrast between the subtler dynamics and lighter, refined orchestration, with the big punchy climaxes is its USP - one of its charms! Leipzig GO at its peak is hard to resist.
( that’s part of the point about the chamber orchestral/HIPPs recordings, you’re arriving at a similar destination to Mahler’s by a different route.
Its not just about density of texture though - there are a host of dynamic changes which freshen and enliven the music, especially enjoyable in No.3, where the horns soar and shine much more brilliantly, clear of those absent wind lines. In the 2nd movement I compared Chailly to Ticciati (one of the “bigger” & more Romantic sounding chamber orch. productions), and was surprised how soon I came to prefer Chailly despite his very fast speeds here. I think he’s going for max clarity of line/rhythm as a match for those fresh, transparent textures…
He can sound overly ebullient and driven, but the effect is undeniably exciting.
Still, there’s always Ceccato if you want a stroll in the sun…
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by Beppe View PostGot this a few days ago and can't stop listening to it.
Jayne Lee Wilson, I heard the BPO/Rattle set recently, which I very much enjoyed. Very polished playing indeed. I don’t know whether Rattle used Mahler’s Edition for this, or not.Don’t cry for me
I go where music was born
J S Bach 1685-1750
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by BBMmk2 View PostI don’t know whether Rattle used Mahler’s Edition for this, or not.
Jayne, did you notice a marked difference in recorded sound between numbers 2 and 3? Moving on from one to the other I had the impression of a suddenly more boxy sound. I had a listen to a bit of Ceccato and, well, if you're going to do them in as relaxed a way as that what's the point in bringing Mahler into the picture at all? I imagine Mahler conducting them with a similar sort of fire to Chailly, although probably without being able to rely on such refined playing. For a soft-grained approach you have Herreweghe, who actually was my way into Schumann's orchestral music.
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by Richard Barrett View PostNo he didn't. As far as I'm aware, only Ceccato and Chailly have recorded those versions.
Jayne, did you notice a marked difference in recorded sound between numbers 2 and 3? Moving on from one to the other I had the impression of a suddenly more boxy sound. I had a listen to a bit of Ceccato and, well, if you're going to do them in as relaxed a way as that what's the point in bringing Mahler into the picture at all? I imagine Mahler conducting them with a similar sort of fire to Chailly, although probably without being able to rely on such refined playing. For a soft-grained approach you have Herreweghe, who actually was my way into Schumann's orchestral music.
A Feast of Christmas Carols
Featuring the Cathedral Choirs of
Durham, Norwich, Southwark and York Minster.Last edited by BBMmk2; 07-12-18, 13:01.Don’t cry for me
I go where music was born
J S Bach 1685-1750
Comment
-
-
CD-Rs (8 in all) derived from Dolby S cassette recordings of the Radio FM broadcasts from the 1996 Ives weekend at the Barbican.
Comment
-
-
Anna Netrebko – ‘Russian Album’
Opera arias from Glinka, Prokofiev, Rachmaninov, Rimsky-Korsakov, Tchaikovsky
Anna Netrebko (soprano)
Chorus and Orchestra of the Mariinsky Theatre / Valery Gergiev
Recorded 2005/06 Mariinsky Theatre, St. Petersburg
Deutsche Grammophon
Scriabin
Complete Preludes
Dmitri Alexeev (piano)
Recorded 2017, Henry Wood Hall, London
Brilliant Classics - new release
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by Stanfordian View Post
Scriabin
Complete Preludes
Dmitri Alexeev (piano)
Recorded 2017, Henry Wood Hall, London
Brilliant Classics - new release
Debussy: Nocturnes
Les Cris de Paris/Les Siècles/François-Xavier Roth
Stravinsky: Agon
Orchestre Philharmonique de Luxembourg/Gustavo Gimeno
Tippett: Symphony No 2
BBC Scottish Symphony Orchestra/Martyn Brabbins
Three of my favourite pieces of music, in new (or newish) recordings. The Debussy, recorded in the very recognisable - and usually very clear - acoustic of the Philharmonie de Paris (occasionally the reverberation at climaxes makes the sound a bit muddied), is, as one might expect from this combination, excellent. The Stravinsky, from a hitherto unheard combination on my part, is really well recorded (Pentatone) and played. It really brings out the fact that it was written as a ballet. And the Tippett doesn't need me to say anything other than to reiterate its excellence (interestingly for a composer not much known in France, the latest Diapason has a lengthy feature about Tippett and his music).
Comment
-
Comment