Originally posted by teamsaint
View Post
New releases
Collapse
This is a sticky topic.
X
X
-
Of course, doing other peoples jobs can be very easy.....politics, football referee, that sort of thing !
Looking at this release, I would have thought that with such a popular work, and this ensemble, BIS would have been reasonably ambitious in its aspirations.
If that is the case, it doesn't seem to me to reflect in the cover. But then, perhaps covers aren't so influential for music as for books , and doubtless they know their market. Perhaps other people like it.
My guess would be that extra resource put into cover design on a CD would go quite a long way. In general they wouldn't incur the extra costs that publishers do for things like textured hardback covers, and all the myriad design features built into many modern book covers. It is probably true to say that good cover design can make a book, in a way that is less likely for a CD.
Oh, and just to add a ( probably obvious )point , publishers would tend to put resource into the covers in proportion to the expected market, very broadly. So that niche titles , with a limited and defined market, will likely get something functional, whereas a title with " Breakout " potential will likely get a bit of extra in the way of bells and whistles in its treatment.Last edited by teamsaint; 03-12-18, 17:49.I will not be pushed, filed, stamped, indexed, briefed, debriefed or numbered. My life is my own.
I am not a number, I am a free man.
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by Richard Barrett View PostThanks, that's all very interesting. I'm sure you've noticed though that some labels, among which I'd count BIS, even though it has improved massively in this regard since the horrible covers they used to do, really don't seem to care very much about what their products look like.
Last edited by jayne lee wilson; 03-12-18, 18:21.
Comment
-
-
Some of the very first BIS CD's recordings I own are emblazoned with a huge red 'WARNING' across the cover, informing listeners that 'the staggering dynamics of the ORIGINAL performance...may damage your loudspeakers.'
However thoughtful that was of them for the listener, it didn't do much for the attractiveness of the covers.
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by MickyD View PostSome of the very first BIS CD's recordings I own are emblazoned with a huge red 'WARNING' across the cover, informing listeners that 'the staggering dynamics of the ORIGINAL performance...may damage your loudspeakers.'
However thoughtful that was of them for the listener, it didn't do much for the attractiveness of the covers.
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by MickyD View PostSome of the very first BIS CD's recordings I own are emblazoned with a huge red 'WARNING' across the cover, informing listeners that 'the staggering dynamics of the ORIGINAL performance...may damage your loudspeakers.'
However thoughtful that was of them for the listener, it didn't do much for the attractiveness of the covers.
I always thought that was a bit of a marketing ploy since I played these discs through everything from a £20 'boom box' to a £100k system with no ill effects.
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by pastoralguy View PostI always thought that was a bit of a marketing ploy since I played these discs through everything from a £20 'boom box' to a £100k system with no ill effects.
In fact, various mini-hifi, portables and boomboxes will exhibit fewer problems as they designedly self-limit. It is really all about the "honesty" of the design: not attempting more than it can reasonably manage (in terms of average power/dynamic capability - which is why some models don't get much more dynamic as the volume increases...)..
It is variable system-to-system of course, but "damage to loudspeakers" is more often caused by amplifier inadequacy (running short of current at higher volumes to cope with climaxes etc), rather than a very powerful amp or recording "overdriving" a loudspeaker.
I always used the Holmboe ( last movement of the Metamorphosis No. 4, Op. 108) when system-building: once I had a speaker/amp combo that could cope with that (and remain natural & pleasant to the ears at higher volume settings), I knew I was getting somewhere....Last edited by jayne lee wilson; 04-12-18, 18:00.
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by vinteuil View Post.
... if you are tempted by the new Carole Cerasi Couperin (and it is marvellous) you might like to know that currently amazon france have it for about half the price of amazon uk :
.
.
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by vinteuil View Post.
... if you are tempted by the new Carole Cerasi Couperin (and it is marvellous) you might like to know that currently amazon france have it for about half the price of amazon uk :
.
.
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by MickyD View PostI already have the complete Rousset set, Vints and love it to bits...what makes this one so special and worth buying, pray tell?
.
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by vinteuil View Post... I've only listened to a little so far - but I agree with the appreciative reviewer on amazon, who makes useful contrasts with the other sets I have on the shelves here - the Kenneth Gilbert, Rousset, Scott Ross, Verlet. Lovely instruments, and fine recorded sound. I've been a Cerasi fan for ages - her Jacquet de La Guerre I hope you already have?
.
Comment
-
Comment