Bruckner: Symphony no. 3 in D minor BaL 31/12/16

[Bryn]

Exactly, but I've (almost) convinced myself that as we have so many good value choices available to us the odd expensive one can be tolerated.


While my wallet gently weeps...........

I got the 10 discs (the 8th is spread over 2) piecemeal, over the years, for rather less than 'list price'. Blomstedt, I think, made fine choices regarding the editions he performed. This with the sole exception of the 8th (his final concert as music director before Chailly took over the job). There he opted for the Haas 'pick and mix'. The booklet notes by Renate Herklotz read somewhat apologetically regarding this choice.

[richardfinegold]

Exactly, but I've (almost) convinced myself that as we have so many good value choices available to us the odd expensive one can be tolerated.


While my wallet gently weeps...........

I feel your pain....I'd like to add a good SACD set of Bruckner, as the more I listen to Simone Young, the less enchanted I am with her...

[vinteuil]

All the Bruckner/LGO/Blomstedt discs are currently indicated as being available from the German version of the Querstand site. Those not on Page 4 are on Page 5. .

... perhaps cheaper (130 euros, plus p&p) from jpc.de

https://www.jpc.de/s/bruckner+blomstedt

[Bryn]

Be quick, only one at this price, £118.21 (if it has not already gone).

[Beef Oven!]

I’ve just downloaded a Hi-Res recording of Skrowaczewski’s LPO B3, a number of months after fellow forumistas urged me to in a recent SS discussion!

I’m tempted to also download the Tennsedt - it sounded very good in this morning’s BaL.

[Petrushka]

I also bought the Blomstedt set piecemeal in the course of a Proms season a couple of years ago, though the cost was reduced by a kind Forumista offering me a free unwanted copy of the double CD 8th. I can confirm that all of the discs are hybrid SACD and play perfectly on normal CD players. I can't say that the 3rd particularly lodged itself in my memory but I'll play it again as soon as I can.

[vinteuil]

I’m tempted to also download the Tennstedt - it sounded very good in this morning’s BaL.

.

... another interesting way to acquire the Tennstedt might be :

http://amzn.eu/67aUyWf

- twenty CDs for some £53 -

Volume 1 (2 CD)
Symphony No. 00 in F minor Study Symphony Symphony No. 0 in D minor Die Nullte³ Royal Scottish National Orchestra National Symphony Orchestra of Ireland Georg Tintner
Volume 2 (1 CD) Symphony No. 1 in C minor Philharmonie Festiva Gerd Schaller
Volume 3 (1 CD) Symphony No. 2 in C minor Philharmonie Festiva Gerd Schaller
Volume 4 (1 CD) Symphony No. 3 in D minor Symphonieorchester des Bayerischen Rundfunks Klaus Tennstedt
Volume 5 (1 CD) Symphony No. 4 in E flat major Symphonieorchester des Bayerischen Rundfunks Kurt Sanderling
Volume 6 (1 CD) Symphony No. 5 in B flat major Deutsches Symphonie-Orchester Berlin Günter Wand
Volume 7 (1 CD) Symphony No. 6 in A major Staatskapelle Dresden Bernard Haitink
Volume 8 (1 CD) Symphony No. 7 in E major Gürzenich-Orchester Köln Yuri Ahronovitch
Volume 9 ( 2 CD) Symphony No. 8 in C minor Staatskapelle Dresden Christian Thielemann
Volume 10 (1 CD) Symphony No. 9 in D minor Radio-Sinfonieorchester Stuttgart des SWR Günter Wand
Volume 11 (1 CD) Latin Motets Philharmonia Vocalensemble Stuttgart Hans Zanotelli
Volume 12 (1 CD) String Quintet in F major String Quartet in C minor Gil Sharon, Viola Fine Arts Quartet
Volume 13 (1 CD) Te Deum Mass E minor
Leontyne Price, soprano, Hilde Rössl-Majdan, mezzo-soprano, Fritz Wunderlich, tenor, Walter Berry, bass, Franz Sauer, organ Singverein der Gesellschaft der Musikfreunde Wien Wiener Philharmoniker, Herbert von Karajan, Henriette Bonde-Hansen, soprano, Iris Vermillion, alt, Michael Schade tenor, Andreas Schmidt, bass Gächinger Kantorei, Bach-Collegium Stuttgart Helmuth Rilling
Volume 14 (1 CD) Mass F minor Psalm 150 Verena Schweizer, soprano, Pamela Coburn, soprano Elisabeth Glaser, alt, Uwe Heilmann, tenor, Matthias Goerne, bass Gächinger Kantorei, Radio-Sinfonieorchester Stuttgart des SWR, Bach-Collegium Stuttgart, Helmuth Rilling
Volume 15 (1 CD) Tantum Ergo, Ave Maria, Helgoland, Mass in C major Windhaager Messe
Martin Haselböck, Johannes Skudlik, organ Dresdner Kreuzchor, Martin Flämig Mikael Stenback, tenor, Daniel Hellström, baritone, Lund Singers, Malmö Opera Orchestra, Albert Hold-Garrido Cornelia Wulkopf, alt, Manfred Neukirchner, Ulrich Kölb, horn
Volume 16 (1 CD) Works for Piano Wolfgang Brunner, piano Michael Schopper, piano
Volume 17 (2 CD) Missa solemnis Psalm 112 March D minor WAB 96 Three Pieces WAB 97 Requiem Christiane Oelze, soprano, Claudia Schubert, alt, Jörg Dürmüller, tenor Reinhart Hagen, bass, Chor der Bamberger Symphoniker Bamberger Symphoniker Karl Anton Rickenbacher Beethovenorchester Bonn, Stefan Blunier Elke Janssens, soprano, Penelope Turner, mezzo, Roel Willems, tenor, Arnout Malfliet, bass, Laudantes Consort, Guy Janssens

[Beef Oven!]

.

... another interesting way to acquire the Tennstedt might be :

http://amzn.eu/67aUyWf

- twenty CDs for some £53 -

Volume 1 (2 CD)
Symphony No. 00 in F minor Study Symphony Symphony No. 0 in D minor Die Nullte³ Royal Scottish National Orchestra National Symphony Orchestra of Ireland Georg Tintner
Volume 2 (1 CD) Symphony No. 1 in C minor Philharmonie Festiva Gerd Schaller
Volume 3 (1 CD) Symphony No. 2 in C minor Philharmonie Festiva Gerd Schaller
Volume 4 (1 CD) Symphony No. 3 in D minor Symphonieorchester des Bayerischen Rundfunks Klaus Tennstedt
Volume 5 (1 CD) Symphony No. 4 in E flat major Symphonieorchester des Bayerischen Rundfunks Kurt Sanderling
Volume 6 (1 CD) Symphony No. 5 in B flat major Deutsches Symphonie-Orchester Berlin Günter Wand
Volume 7 (1 CD) Symphony No. 6 in A major Staatskapelle Dresden Bernard Haitink
Volume 8 (1 CD) Symphony No. 7 in E major Gürzenich-Orchester Köln Yuri Ahronovitch
Volume 9 ( 2 CD) Symphony No. 8 in C minor Staatskapelle Dresden Christian Thielemann
Volume 10 (1 CD) Symphony No. 9 in D minor Radio-Sinfonieorchester Stuttgart des SWR Günter Wand
Volume 11 (1 CD) Latin Motets Philharmonia Vocalensemble Stuttgart Hans Zanotelli
Volume 12 (1 CD) String Quintet in F major String Quartet in C minor Gil Sharon, Viola Fine Arts Quartet
Volume 13 (1 CD) Te Deum Mass E minor
Leontyne Price, soprano, Hilde Rössl-Majdan, mezzo-soprano, Fritz Wunderlich, tenor, Walter Berry, bass, Franz Sauer, organ Singverein der Gesellschaft der Musikfreunde Wien Wiener Philharmoniker, Herbert von Karajan, Henriette Bonde-Hansen, soprano, Iris Vermillion, alt, Michael Schade tenor, Andreas Schmidt, bass Gächinger Kantorei, Bach-Collegium Stuttgart Helmuth Rilling
Volume 14 (1 CD) Mass F minor Psalm 150 Verena Schweizer, soprano, Pamela Coburn, soprano Elisabeth Glaser, alt, Uwe Heilmann, tenor, Matthias Goerne, bass Gächinger Kantorei, Radio-Sinfonieorchester Stuttgart des SWR, Bach-Collegium Stuttgart, Helmuth Rilling
Volume 15 (1 CD) Tantum Ergo, Ave Maria, Helgoland, Mass in C major Windhaager Messe
Martin Haselböck, Johannes Skudlik, organ Dresdner Kreuzchor, Martin Flämig Mikael Stenback, tenor, Daniel Hellström, baritone, Lund Singers, Malmö Opera Orchestra, Albert Hold-Garrido Cornelia Wulkopf, alt, Manfred Neukirchner, Ulrich Kölb, horn
Volume 16 (1 CD) Works for Piano Wolfgang Brunner, piano Michael Schopper, piano
Volume 17 (2 CD) Missa solemnis Psalm 112 March D minor WAB 96 Three Pieces WAB 97 Requiem Christiane Oelze, soprano, Claudia Schubert, alt, Jörg Dürmüller, tenor Reinhart Hagen, bass, Chor der Bamberger Symphoniker Bamberger Symphoniker Karl Anton Rickenbacher Beethovenorchester Bonn, Stefan Blunier Elke Janssens, soprano, Penelope Turner, mezzo, Roel Willems, tenor, Arnout Malfliet, bass, Laudantes Consort, Guy Janssens

Wow! That’s an incredible box. I had no idea it existed. Sadly, I have a fair few doubles, including the more interesting ones, so it might not work out for me. It would have certainly been a much cheaper way of acquiring the ones I already have, never mind the extras.

(I don’t understand how you guys find these things!!)

[Alison]

Only just listened via I player. The intention was to listen before messageboarding but it quickly became clear Blomstedt was going to win and so hurried over to the forum. Like many I like neither the obvious early winner nor the come from nowhere get up on the line type!

A good effort from Tom and we weren't reduced to version city as feared. It seemed a slightly shorter BAL if anything.

Often disappointed by Blomstedt, I'm not joining in the scrum to acquire the winner.
Have a feeling I've got the Tennstedt in the garage overflow boxes!

[Nick Armstrong]

It was very obvious (unless TS was going to do an Agatha Christie, and recommend a completely unexpected recording, like the Ballot) who was going to "win" - every time Blomstedt was mentioned, the tone of his voice lifted into reverential awe.

I really think I am going to sit this BAL out... Didn't listen this morning, don't feel I need TS - either to feature at the start of 2017, or to add to my various B3s

But I'm certainly going to buy the LPO/Skrowaczewski

Great decision! It remains my favourite by some margin

By the way - does anyone else find themselves listening to BaLs these days with a "subtext" running through their minds on the lines of "Ooh! Cali ain't gonna like that!" or "Barbi's going to need an extra Remipril now"?

Well in this case: Cali ain't gonna hear that!

[jayne lee wilson]

"Blomstedt also favours the original 1873 version of the Wagner-inspired 3rd Symphony, where he elicits sumptuous playing from the orchestra and reveals more persuasively than any previous conductor why, structurally and imaginatively, this should be the preferred performing version."

Richard Osborne, reviewing the complete Leipzig cycle, Gramophone 11/2013.


More from me on this excellent BaL (more essay than survey, and very aptly too) tomorrow I hope, heads permitting. The night is young....

[Beef Oven!]

Only just listened via I player. The intention was to listen before messageboarding but it quickly became clear Blomstedt was going to win and so hurried over to the forum. Like many I like neither the obvious early winner nor the come from nowhere get up on the line type!

A good effort from Tom and we weren't reduced to version city as feared. It seemed a slightly shorter BAL if anything.

Often disappointed by Blomstedt, I'm not joining in the scrum to acquire the winner.
Have a feeling I've got the Tennstedt in the garage overflow boxes!

Yes, it was quite obvious that he had a preference for the Blomstedt, from the word go. I was most impressed with the Tennstedt and Skowaczewsski LPO and should have bought them long ago (I was advised to, on here!). Having played SS’s performance tonight I thought it was marvellous. But I also listened to the Sinopoli again straight after and think that’s even better!


I also couldn’t resist buying the download of the shortest available recording at under 48 mins - Mozarteumorchester Salzburg, Zoltán Fekete (1889 Version, Mono Version). It was only £1.99 for a Hi-Res download from Qobuz.

And like you, I was relieved that TS did not get bogged down about versions. He said what had to be said and then moved on.

I’m not going to get join the scrummage to buy the Blomstedt either (as much as he is a long firm-favourite musician for me). I was also alarmed by ferney’s point about the inaudible trumpet



My first thoughts straight after the BaL .....

It was a tightly argued, well presented BaL. What to include and what to leave out was handled judiciously, IMV.

Editions/versions minefield was dealt with singularly and expeditiously - Well done TS!!

[ferneyhoughgeliebte]

I was also alarmed by ferney’s point about the inaudible trumpet

I shall listen on a better system and with total concentration - surely if it was as difficult to hear as it sounded on my kitchen radio (although the ostinato was very clear) then TS or somebody would have commented?!

[Beef Oven!]

I shall listen on a better system and with total concentration - surely if it was as difficult to hear as it sounded on my kitchen radio (although the ostinato was very clear) then TS or somebody would have commented?!

Bruckner: ''The one with the trumpet!!?"
Wagner: "Yes!!!"

[ferneyhoughgeliebte]

Bruckner: ''The one with the trumpet!!?"
Wagner: "Yes!!!"