Originally posted by Barbirollians
View Post
I was more impressed with the Rachmaninoff than you were, Barbs, and want to hear more of it. I was distinctly underwhelmed by Blomstedt's Mozza #40 (I prefer a "grainier", more urgent approach - but for those who prefer a smoother, more lyrical performance I can see that this would have its appeal), and was more involved in #42, though not to the extent that I would wish to buy the disc. (If I'd heard this in concert, I'd've thought it a very good performance, without getting anything particularly "special" from it.)
Good to hear Chineke playing something more substantial than the "Classical Pops" I'd only heard them in before - I agree, a very good Sibelius #2, but not quite the overwhelming experience that Ms Molleson's enthusiasm led me to expect (perhaps the whole work creates more of an impact) - and I enjoyed the bit of the Rachmaninoff #3 we heard, without it matching memories of the best recordings, broadcasts, and performances I've experienced. I'd be keener to buy this disc than the Blomstedt, though.
On the whole, I think I'll save my money for bringing my Gibbons collection up-to-date, and seeing what's on offer next week after the Purcell BaL.
Comment