Kopatchinskja, Orchestra des Champs-Elysees, Herreweghe
BaL 9.04.11 - Beethoven: Violin Concerto
Collapse
X
-
amateur51
Originally posted by mikealdren View PostStrangely neither of his studio performances is listed - Toscanini and Munch.
Mike
I was pleased to see a strong recommendation from Roehre for the Krebbers/Haitink version earlier on this thread
Comment
-
Originally posted by verismissimo View PostOf the several recordings I appear to have, for sheer pleasure I reach most often for Campoli with RPO/Pritchard.
Not available I guess.
I bought it on the DVD - sounds like the cleanest LP played on excellent equipment - having previously suggested to EMI it be released for Campoli's centenary.
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by pilamenon View PostGiven the reviewer is Roy Goodman"...the isle is full of noises,
Sounds and sweet airs, that give delight and hurt not.
Sometimes a thousand twangling instruments
Will hum about mine ears, and sometime voices..."
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by verismissimo View PostOf the several recordings I appear to have, for sheer pleasure I reach most often for Campoli with RPO/Pritchard.
Not available I guess.
Comment
-
-
Post 1, Eine Alpensinfonie
I've got quite a few LP versions that arent on your list, though of course, it may be that they never made it to CD, or are unavailable:
Francescatti/Walter/Columbia SO
stereo CBS (UK) SBRG 72006 (USA Columbia MS 6263)
Francescatti/Ormandy/ Columbia SO
mono Columbia 33CX 1011
Ferras/Karajan/BPO
stereo DG SLPM 139 021
Schneiderhan/Jochum/BPO
stereo DG SLPM 138 999
Schneiderhan/van Kempen/BPO
mono DG LPM 18099
Suk/Boult/New Philharmonia
stereo HMV ASD 2667
David Oistrakh/Gauk/USSR State O.
stereo Vox STPL 516.160
Menuhin/Silvestri/VPO
stereo HMV ASD 377
Igor Oistrakh/Schuchter/Pro Arte O.
mono Columbia 33CX 1514
Since I've also got quite a few of the ones that are on your list I think I might give this BAL a miss, I've really got enough versions of Beetoven's violin concerto!
Comment
-
-
Alf-Prufrock
A modest request
I am somewhat embarrassed to find that I have seventeen performances of the concerto in my collection (all CDs as I got rid of LPs for space reasons (!!) many years ago.) But I have managed not to have an Oistrakh version, though over the years I have heard several of them. My memory of them is too vague to recall orchestras, companies, etc.
Which Oistrakh version would members advise? I should prefer stereo, though good mono is not discounted. (Please, no dreadful Russian engineering of the old style such as is beloved of Rob Cowan.)
Comment
-
Hello Alf-Prufrock (msg 24)
Nothing embarrassing about 17 performances of this! In fact a great achievement - something to cherish, I'd say.... I think I have 2 or 3 Oistrakhs - and Kogan with Silvestri (EMI) is a sure-fire all guns blazing tour de force... but I have I have Szeryng, Krebbers, Schneiderhahn, etc - also a version from Berlin in 1943, I think with Furtwangler, which is quite brilliant, but sadly the thoughts of what was going on a few kilometres to the east, and also who may have been attending the concert, somewhat overshadow my enjoyment, to say the least.
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by visualnickmos View PostHello Alf-Prufrock (msg 24)
Nothing embarrassing about 17 performances of this! In fact a great achievement - something to cherish, I'd say.... I think I have 2 or 3 Oistrakhs - and Kogan with Silvestri (EMI) is a sure-fire all guns blazing tour de force... but I have I have Szeryng, Krebbers, Schneiderhahn, etc - also a version from Berlin in 1943, I think with Furtwangler, which is quite brilliant, but sadly the thoughts of what was going on a few kilometres to the east, and also who may have been attending the concert, somewhat overshadow my enjoyment, to say the least."The sound is the handwriting of the conductor" - Bernard Haitink
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by pastoralguy View PostMay I mention Accardo with Guilini on Sony? A good if not perhaps great recording."The sound is the handwriting of the conductor" - Bernard Haitink
Comment
-
Comment