The Eternal Breakfast Debate in a New Place

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • antongould
    Full Member
    • Nov 2010
    • 8778

    Originally posted by oddoneout View Post
    He's (IS that is not Anton) been very much in evidence in the afternoon slot and I couldn't help thinking that was deliberate of the Beeb -"Look we're not getting rid of him" deflection tactic.
    I would agree odders .....

    Comment

    • Serial_Apologist
      Full Member
      • Dec 2010
      • 37589

      Originally posted by Heldenleben View Post
      A propos of Sounds Of the Earth does any one agree that mixing natural sounds e,g, birdsong and classical music doesn’t really work? To be the beauties of one fight against the beauties of the other . The audio recording of the cellist and the nightingale constantly rolled out on Radio 3 is one of my least favourite radio cliches . Partly because the cello playing has some poor intonation. On a bigger scale the Rautavarra works are very interesting - once ...There is wonderful blackbird that wakes me up every morning at the moment in the front garden. It is quite pleasant when aleatorically he joins in with Radio 3 but having it mixed together by an engineer is to my ears unnaturally premeditated.
      Don't you ever pine for Rome?

      Comment

      • Eine Alpensinfonie
        Host
        • Nov 2010
        • 20570

        Originally posted by Serial_Apologist View Post
        Don't you ever pine for Rome?
        I'm surprised that HIPP fanatics don't insist that a scratchy, pre-electric recording of a nightingale is used in The Pines of Rome. After all, "that's what the composer expected".

        Comment

        • hmvman
          Full Member
          • Mar 2007
          • 1097

          Originally posted by Eine Alpensinfonie View Post
          I'm surprised that HIPP fanatics don't insist that a scratchy, pre-electric recording of a nightingale is used in The Pines of Rome. After all, "that's what the composer expected".
          I believe he was very specific about which record to use.

          Comment

          • Ein Heldenleben
            Full Member
            • Apr 2014
            • 6740

            Originally posted by Serial_Apologist View Post
            Don't you ever pine for Rome?
            Don’t mind that one so much . Bit ambivalent about Resphigi - I sort of like his stuff but think I shouldn’t ....

            Comment

            • Serial_Apologist
              Full Member
              • Dec 2010
              • 37589

              Originally posted by Eine Alpensinfonie View Post
              I'm surprised that HIPP fanatics don't insist that a scratchy, pre-electric recording of a nightingale is used in The Pines of Rome. After all, "that's what the composer expected".
              We're in danger of getting into "wouldn't Beethoven have composed for a modern Bechstein?" territory!

              Comment

              • Serial_Apologist
                Full Member
                • Dec 2010
                • 37589

                Originally posted by Heldenleben View Post
                Don’t mind that one so much . Bit ambivalent about Resphigi - I sort of like his stuff but think I shouldn’t ....
                Respighi was a fine composer, comparable in many ways to Bax: similar style and mix of influences - Wagner, Strauss, Mahler, Debussy, Petrushka-era Stravinsky.

                Comment

                • seabright
                  Full Member
                  • Jan 2013
                  • 625

                  Originally posted by hmvman View Post
                  I believe he was very specific about which record to use.
                  Indeed he was. The score states: "No. R. 6105 del 'Concert Record' Gramophone: Il canto dell'usignolo" ... Of course, that wasn't the recording we heard on Sunday in the Stokowski performance to mark his birthday on 18th April 1882 and Respighi's death day on 18th April 1936. You can however hear it on YouTube in the 1928 Columbia 78rpm recording made by Lorenzo Molajoli and the Milan Symphony Orchestra. The nightingale comes in just after the 12-minute mark ...

                  The Pines of Rome (1924), by Ottorino Respighi (1879 -- 1936). The Milan Symphony Orchestra, conducted by Cav. Lorenzo Molajoli (1868 - 1939), recorded Novem...


                  Curiously, at exactly the same time that Molajoli was recording the work for Columbia, Ettore Panizza and the Orchestra della Scala di Milano were recording a rival version for Odeon. Unfortunately that isn't on YouTube (yet!) but we must assume they too used the same nightingale 78.

                  It's also curious that although Bernardino Molinari had given the work its premiere in 1924, it wasn't performed at the Proms until 1986. Happily that is also on YouTube, with Edward Downes and the BBC Philharmonic bringing the house down with Respighi's depiction of ancient Roman legions marching up the Appian way, the bass drum thwacks and the organ pedals at the end causing the Prommers to erupt into a state of extreme excitement ...

                  Respighi's most popular 'tone poem for orchestra' had its first performance in 1924 yet had to wait over 60 years to receive its Proms Premiere in London's R...


                  And we still haven't heard the equally spectacular "Church Windows" at the Proms. I wonder if we ever will.

                  Comment

                  • Eine Alpensinfonie
                    Host
                    • Nov 2010
                    • 20570

                    Originally posted by hmvman View Post
                    I believe he was very specific about which record to use.

                    There’s a recording on YouTube that claims to be the original one that Respighi used. I suspect it’s a fake, as the frequency response is so good and the background noise is negligible.

                    Comment

                    • cloughie
                      Full Member
                      • Dec 2011
                      • 22114

                      Originally posted by Eine Alpensinfonie View Post
                      There’s a recording on YouTube that claims to be the original one that Respighi used. I suspect it’s a fake, as the frequency response is so good and the background noise is negligible.
                      The Respighi Berkeley Square Hoax?

                      Comment

                      • Ein Heldenleben
                        Full Member
                        • Apr 2014
                        • 6740

                        Originally posted by seabright View Post
                        Indeed he was. The score states: "No. R. 6105 del 'Concert Record' Gramophone: Il canto dell'usignolo" ... Of course, that wasn't the recording we heard on Sunday in the Stokowski performance to mark his birthday on 18th April 1882 and Respighi's death day on 18th April 1936. You can however hear it on YouTube in the 1928 Columbia 78rpm recording made by Lorenzo Molajoli and the Milan Symphony Orchestra. The nightingale comes in just after the 12-minute mark ...

                        The Pines of Rome (1924), by Ottorino Respighi (1879 -- 1936). The Milan Symphony Orchestra, conducted by Cav. Lorenzo Molajoli (1868 - 1939), recorded Novem...


                        Curiously, at exactly the same time that Molajoli was recording the work for Columbia, Ettore Panizza and the Orchestra della Scala di Milano were recording a rival version for Odeon. Unfortunately that isn't on YouTube (yet!) but we must assume they too used the same nightingale 78.

                        It's also curious that although Bernardino Molinari had given the work its premiere in 1924, it wasn't performed at the Proms until 1986. Happily that is also on YouTube, with Edward Downes and the BBC Philharmonic bringing the house down with Respighi's depiction of ancient Roman legions marching up the Appian way, the bass drum thwacks and the organ pedals at the end causing the Prommers to erupt into a state of extreme excitement ...

                        Respighi's most popular 'tone poem for orchestra' had its first performance in 1924 yet had to wait over 60 years to receive its Proms Premiere in London's R...


                        And we still haven't heard the equally spectacular "Church Windows" at the Proms. I wonder if we ever will.
                        Danger of going off thread here but I wonder if he was linked , probably unfairly , with Mussolini in the public and concert promoters minds. His music was against trend and also , in some cases expensive to perform . A nightingale record is cheap but doesn’t the score also need some rare offstage horns ?

                        Comment

                        • hmvman
                          Full Member
                          • Mar 2007
                          • 1097

                          Originally posted by seabright View Post
                          Indeed he was. The score states: "No. R. 6105 del 'Concert Record' Gramophone: Il canto dell'usignolo" ... Of course, that wasn't the recording we heard on Sunday in the Stokowski performance to mark his birthday on 18th April 1882 and Respighi's death day on 18th April 1936. You can however hear it on YouTube in the 1928 Columbia 78rpm recording made by Lorenzo Molajoli and the Milan Symphony Orchestra. The nightingale comes in just after the 12-minute mark ...

                          The Pines of Rome (1924), by Ottorino Respighi (1879 -- 1936). The Milan Symphony Orchestra, conducted by Cav. Lorenzo Molajoli (1868 - 1939), recorded Novem...


                          Curiously, at exactly the same time that Molajoli was recording the work for Columbia, Ettore Panizza and the Orchestra della Scala di Milano were recording a rival version for Odeon. Unfortunately that isn't on YouTube (yet!) but we must assume they too used the same nightingale 78.

                          It's also curious that although Bernardino Molinari had given the work its premiere in 1924, it wasn't performed at the Proms until 1986. Happily that is also on YouTube, with Edward Downes and the BBC Philharmonic bringing the house down with Respighi's depiction of ancient Roman legions marching up the Appian way, the bass drum thwacks and the organ pedals at the end causing the Prommers to erupt into a state of extreme excitement ...

                          Respighi's most popular 'tone poem for orchestra' had its first performance in 1924 yet had to wait over 60 years to receive its Proms Premiere in London's R...


                          And we still haven't heard the equally spectacular "Church Windows" at the Proms. I wonder if we ever will.
                          Thanks for all that info, seabright, I shall check out those YouTube links. As I understand it, the scoring for harp and strings in the Nightingale section was to mask the surface noise of the gramophone record (which may address Eine Alpensinfonie's point). I've also read that at the first performance the gramophone was concealed behind a heavy curtain which would also have attenuated record surface noise.

                          That's incredible that 'Pines' wasn't performed at the Proms until so comparatively recently. A few years ago I was at a Proms performance of 'Roman Festivals' conducted by John Adams.

                          Comment

                          • seabright
                            Full Member
                            • Jan 2013
                            • 625

                            Originally posted by Eine Alpensinfonie View Post
                            There’s a recording on YouTube that claims to be the original one that Respighi used. I suspect it’s a fake, as the frequency response is so good and the background noise is negligible.
                            You are quite right to suspect fakery! ... I just googled the Catalogue No. quoted in the Respighi score and was immediately taken to a website that lists historical recordings. This one was recorded by one Karl Reich in May 1913 and issued in Italy on the 'Gramophone' label. There's no way that an ancient pre-electric acoustically recorded 78, with the bird chirping into a giant wooden horn, could possibly sound like the version claimed to be the "original" on YouTube. On the other hand, when the uploader says it's a "copy" of the original recording, I wonder if he means that literally. It's an 8-minute video of a nightingale and I'm beginning to suspect he means it's for general use whenever someone performs the work and needs a handy nightingale to play in the hall. His words that it's a "service to all artists performing this piece" does rather suggest this. Nevertheless, his comment about it being a "copy" of the original is misleading, as some of the comments under the soon show.

                            Comment

                            • Serial_Apologist
                              Full Member
                              • Dec 2010
                              • 37589

                              Originally posted by cloughie View Post
                              The Respighi Berkeley Square Hoax?
                              "Ain't there some bird sang about that place?" - Count Basie to a late friend of mine!

                              Comment

                              • cloughie
                                Full Member
                                • Dec 2011
                                • 22114

                                Originally posted by Serial_Apologist View Post
                                "Ain't there some bird sang about that place?" - Count Basie to a late friend of mine!
                                Wasn’t he in Paris that same April?

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X