Report from the Oilfields in Baku. ( Walküre Bayreuth 2013 production)
Act 1 was excellent Botha , Kampe and Selig all sang well, she was even better than at the Proms. Petrenko excellent.
Sounds like Kampe and Botha are the best of it. The Brünnhilde(Catherine Foster) is very shaky and the Wotan (Wolfgang Koch) is overparted.
The Todesverkündigung is about the weakest I have heard. She is not bad when she sings out, but she is holding back trying to save her resources and sounds dreadful at mezzovoce.
Thought so, She saved it for Act 3, and finished well. Koch is giving his all but it is only adequate. He reminds me of Philip Joll, when he first sang Wotan with Reggie in Cardiff in 1984, and that was a much smaller theatre. All middle and higher register , very thin and no bottom to the voice. He is a baritone and that is not enough for this role.
Petrenko is doing well. Very sensitive conducting. I look forwards to hearing more from him when he moves to Munich this Autumn.
Act 1 was excellent Botha , Kampe and Selig all sang well, she was even better than at the Proms. Petrenko excellent.
Sounds like Kampe and Botha are the best of it. The Brünnhilde(Catherine Foster) is very shaky and the Wotan (Wolfgang Koch) is overparted.
The Todesverkündigung is about the weakest I have heard. She is not bad when she sings out, but she is holding back trying to save her resources and sounds dreadful at mezzovoce.
Thought so, She saved it for Act 3, and finished well. Koch is giving his all but it is only adequate. He reminds me of Philip Joll, when he first sang Wotan with Reggie in Cardiff in 1984, and that was a much smaller theatre. All middle and higher register , very thin and no bottom to the voice. He is a baritone and that is not enough for this role.
Petrenko is doing well. Very sensitive conducting. I look forwards to hearing more from him when he moves to Munich this Autumn.
Comment