Terfel

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Mandryka
    • Dec 2024

    Terfel

    When booking my tickets for the 2012 ROH Ring yesterday, a somewhat unworthy thought crossed my mind:

    'Wouldn't it be agreeable if Terfel walked out of this one, too, and was replaced by someone like Rene Pape?'

    This beguiling possibility led me to reflect on my own feelings about this wayward Welshman and the amount of pampering and indulgence of which he seems to be the not very grateful recipient. His welshing (an unfortunate but apposite pun!) on his contract in 2007 (on the pretext of being so scared of Mrs. Terfel's temper that he didn't dare absent himself from the marital home when his son was nursing a poorly finger) was surely disgraceful.....many people, self included, expected him to never be seen at Covent Garden again during Pappano's reign. Yet, the following season, he was back (as Scarpia).

    Presumably, this is because money talks....Terfel is, so we are told, 'big box office': furthermore, his name adds prestige to an event - anything with him in it is automatically a 'major' production. Never mind that Terfel's fee is now apparently beyond the reach of Covent Garden's own pockets (the inserted phrase 'Bryn Terfel's performance by kind permission of (private donor)' has become a common sight in opera programmes around the world) and that his - now fairly rare - opera appearances seem to be grudgingly undertaken, diverting him as they do from his lucrative '2nd career' as a crossover artist (though has anyone else noted how frequently his easy listening CDs turn up in charity shops?).

    What did for me with Terfel was his decision to take a Walkure curtain call while wearing a Welsh flag over his cloak (Wales had just won some rugby match, apparently). I'm sure the stage managers were horrified but 'big Bryn' has so much clout that they would have been powerless to stop him. With this one stupid, arrogant and (typically) selfish gesture, he undermined the powerful effect that he and Lisa Gasteen had achieved in the closing scene of the piece.

    Terfel has been abritrarily blessed with an excellent natural instrument: such a pity that said instrument has to be attached to the brain of a nogood boyo. Personally, I'd be highly delighted if he decided to forsake opera for good (let's face it, he just doesn't have the discipline to realise his potential) and leave the field - particularly of Wagnerian music drama - to more serious singers, who appreciate the opportunities offered to them.
    Last edited by Guest; 26-10-11, 15:01.
  • Nick Armstrong
    Host
    • Nov 2010
    • 26572

    #2
    My first reaction to this new thread was - o no, Bryn Terfel's not dead is he??!?

    (Thought maybe you'd dropped the terminal adjective from your subject headings following the recent debate)

    I was relieved to read on. Great voice in the right context but I confess to some annoyance at his persona.

    N
    "...the isle is full of noises,
    Sounds and sweet airs, that give delight and hurt not.
    Sometimes a thousand twangling instruments
    Will hum about mine ears, and sometime voices..."

    Comment

    • Mary Chambers
      Full Member
      • Nov 2010
      • 1963

      #3
      I have to admit that Mandryka's post made me laugh (and nod in agreement to some extent). I avoid Terfel myself.

      Comment

      • Richard Tarleton

        #4
        Originally posted by Mandryka View Post
        When booking my tickets for the 2012 ROH Ring yesterday, a somewhat unworthy thought crossed my mind:

        'Wouldn't it be agreeable if Terfel walked out of this one, too, and was replaced by someone like Rene Pape?'
        Mandryka, your analysis is spot-on. My Ring buddy and I are booked up for the 3rd cycle next October and a similar thought occurred to me. I went to the last ROH Ring in Oct 2007 and we booked for the only cycle with Tomlinson slated as Wotan (also the one that had Domingo's Siegmund) so as to avoid the boyo. In the event Tomlinson did the lot - I think I've got that right. I might have been tempted by the WNO Meistersinger (my favourite opera of all, and in Cardiff) but could not stand the thought of Terfel as Hans Sachs. Since one gets a chance of so few Rings in one's lifetime (unless one is very rich) one has to take the rough with the smooth and I'm hoping Terfel is offset by a better Siegfried this time round. It's so rare to get perfect casting - the Jones Ring came close, with Jerusalem, Jones/Polaski, Tomlinson in good voice, Graham Clark and many more.
        Last edited by Guest; 26-10-11, 14:53. Reason: sp

        Comment

        • Mandryka

          #5
          An old news article from the Telegraph, in the fall-out of Terfel's Ring walkout:



          Some of the comments below the article characterise the writer as 'sexist'. Maybe so, but I think the point that Christiansen makes is totally valid and the examples he cites of singers with the correct sense of responsibilities is bang on the money.

          Comment

          • Mandryka

            #6
            Originally posted by Richard Tarleton View Post
            Mandryka, your analysis is spot-on. My Ring buddy and I are booked up for the 3rd cycle next October and a similar thought occurred to me. I went to the last ROH Ring in Oct 2007 and we booked for the only cycle with Tomlinson slated as Wotan (also the one that had Domingo's Siegmund) so as to avoid the boyo. In the event Tomlinson did the lot - I think I've got that right. I might have been tempted by the WNO Meistersinger (my favourite opera of all, and in Cardiff) but could not stand the thought of Terfel as Hans Sachs. Since one gets a chance of so few Rings in one's lifetime (unless one is very rich) one has to take the rough with the smooth and I'm hoping Terfel is offset by a better Siegfried this time round. It's so rare to get perfect casting - the Jones Ring came close, with Jerusalem, Jones/Polaski, Tomlinson in good voice, Graham Clark and many more.
            Yes, Richard, I think many would agree that the last ROH Ring cycle worked very much as a 'holding operation': for all that it was nice to see Tomlinson as Wotan, I don't think he could really do the role justice any more by that point and Treleaven was very much a pis aller Siegfried. The production also seemed not fully thought through in parts and the production of Siegfried - I'd say the hardest of the four operas to bring off - was massively unmemorable (in fact, apart from the opening, I can't recall a thing about it).

            Comment

            • Richard Tarleton

              #7
              Originally posted by Mandryka View Post
              (in fact, apart from the opening, I can't recall a thing about it).
              I do remember, after the Act 3 confrontation with Wotan, distinctly hearing John Treleaven calling "The sword's broken, the sword's broken" to the stage hands .

              Comment

              • Mandryka

                #8
                Originally posted by Richard Tarleton View Post
                I do remember, after the Act 3 confrontation with Wotan, distinctly hearing John Treleaven calling "The sword's broken, the sword's broken" to the stage hands .


                Wish I'd been within earshot!

                Comment

                • Biffo

                  #9
                  We always remember the wrong/irrelevant things. I clearly remember an ENO/Siegfried where the anvil slipped in half prematurely; Gregory Dempsey (Mime) saved the day by giving it a sharp kick at the appropriate moment.

                  Comment

                  • amateur51

                    #10
                    And alternative point of view, from the Daily Mail of all places

                    He is the opera superstar who was rehearsing his biggest ever role. She is the uncomplaining wife who, 300 miles away, was single-handedly raising his three children. But then their son had an accident that turned Mrs Bryn Terfel into the wife who said NO


                    And if Bryn does pull out again, I'll gladly go in your stead

                    Comment

                    • french frank
                      Administrator/Moderator
                      • Feb 2007
                      • 30455

                      #11
                      Originally posted by amateur51 View Post
                      And alternative point of view, from the Daily Mail of all places

                      http://www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/ar...lked-year.html
                      And I think that's absolutely fair. Bryn puts his family first (and why not?) - perhaps he should look for a job that doesn't expect him to put the job first? Opera companies invest huge amounts in their productions - including their stars. I'm rather surprised with all he earns that the little woman back home is coping entirely on her own!
                      It isn't given us to know those rare moments when people are wide open and the lightest touch can wither or heal. A moment too late and we can never reach them any more in this world.

                      Comment

                      • amateur51

                        #12
                        Where Beckham leads ...



                        Both a case of 'damned if you do, damned if you don't' I reckon.

                        Comment

                        • Mandryka

                          #13
                          Originally posted by amateur51 View Post
                          And alternative point of view, from the Daily Mail of all places

                          He is the opera superstar who was rehearsing his biggest ever role. She is the uncomplaining wife who, 300 miles away, was single-handedly raising his three children. But then their son had an accident that turned Mrs Bryn Terfel into the wife who said NO


                          And if Bryn does pull out again, I'll gladly go in your stead

                          I remember reading that article at the time: it smells strongly of 'crisis management'.

                          I wonder if a four star general would be allowed to absent himself from his army at an equivalent crisis point? If a captain of industry would be allowed to check out for a bit during a takeover bid? If a Prime Minister or a President would be allowed to take some 'family time' out during a political crisis? Because that's exactly what Terfel did over the 2007 Ring.

                          Personally, I'd like to see him retire from opera altogether: it's a grown-up's job, not a boy-child's.

                          Comment

                          • amateur51

                            #14
                            Originally posted by Mandryka View Post
                            I remember reading that article at the time: it smells strongly of 'crisis management'.
                            Oh Mandy, you're soooo jaundiced



                            I recall that nice John Major had a bad touch of toothache during Thatcher's downfall vote.

                            And that glamorous Anthony Eden had 'bad nerves' after Suez amongst a litany of poorlinesses and heavy use of prescription and non-prescription drugs

                            Comment

                            • Mandryka

                              #15
                              Yes, and remember 'spending more time with my family'? All the rage amongst Thatcher cabinet ministers during 1990....before being resurrected by B.Terfel in 2007 (which is where we came in).

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X