Mozart and Britten with Thomas Zehetmair and the Royal Northern Sinfonia

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • edashtav
    Full Member
    • Jul 2012
    • 3670

    Mozart and Britten with Thomas Zehetmair and the Royal Northern Sinfonia

    Royal Northern Sinfonia live from The Sage, Gateshead presented by Adam Tomlinson at 7.30pm Friday 25th October, 2013
    Werner Güra (tenor) Peter Francomb (horn) Thomas Zehetmair (conductor)

    Mozart: Divertimento in B flat 'Salzburg Symphony No. 2', K137
    Britten: Serenade for Tenor, Horn and Strings
    Mozart: Symphony No 40 in G minor, K550

    I’ve been catching up with this Concert little by little on iPlayer and have found a great deal to admire and am disappointed that no other For3 boarders seem to have bothered with it. It’s time, perhaps, to salute the great work done by Thomas Zehetmair over the last decade or more with “his” orchestra, especially as he intends to move in 2014 when he’ll assume the role of “conductor laureate” of this royal band.

    Why do I admire his work so? I think it’s because of the complete absence of dull routine. Every phrase and each blend of instrumental tone emerges fresh and brightly polished. Thomas is, of course, a great violinist and the orchestra has a winning string body that shows an ability to be light, marvellously unanimous but can burgeon into a rich refulgence when context so demands. This concert started with Mozart’s delightful Divertimento in Bb that was played beautifully with sprung rhythms to the fore together with a relaxed manner – players knew their parts well and communicated a sense that “we’re having fun”.

    It was good to hear Britten’s masterly Serenade sung in pretty idiomatic English by the young German tenor, Walter Gura. He exhibited a range of vocal timbres to suit the great variety of poetry in the seven songs. The excellent horn soloist was Peter Francomb, who is a member of the orchestra.

    Mozart’s 40th Symphony is very familiar but it came over newly imagined by Thomas Zahetmair. The first movement was quick, light and pointed. That might not please all listeners but the manner in which its style was unified from the smallest accompanying figure to full-blown climaxes was admirable. Zehetmair chose Mozart’s revised version with added clarinets.

    I’d characterise his whole approach as nearer to Robert Schumann’s concept that this G minor symphony is full of “Grecian lightness and grace", or Tovey’s idea that it's “opera buffa” than 20th century critics who huddle around Charles Rosen as he declares it “a work of passion, violence and grief”.

    Few days left on the iPlayer’s clock. I do commend these sparkling performances to you.
    Last edited by edashtav; 29-10-13, 08:49. Reason: typo
  • Thropplenoggin
    Full Member
    • Mar 2013
    • 1587

    #2
    Thank you for starting this thread, which I was reluctant to do, as I only wanted to moan about the poorness of the presenter.

    The introductions by Adam Tomlinson were wince-inducing. Utterly crass. Faux bonhomie - 'the atmosphere is buzzin' tonight'. Expressions such as how Mozart 'loved to go to the pub with his friends'...and then relating the Divertimento to this notion. Zounds! Talk about destroy one's mood as you prepare to 'enter' an audible landscape. My hackles were raised. What chance to Zehetmair & Co. stand?

    Trying to 'big up' the symphony, the 'glorious' Symphony No. 40, saying its one of his most popular. What does this even mean?! Where is the musicological and historical good sense of, say, Stephen Johnson? No transfiguration, certainly not in K. 550. I'm with Rosen. Can you really call it 'glorious'? The Jupiter, yes! But K.550? One pictures the Agony of Christ on the Cross. The dying of a star. But not glory, surely?!

    I liked the programme. I wish there was more Mozart programmed, and sandwiching Britten in between the two works was a nice touch. I didn't think these were stellar performances, though - not 'premier division' to go all Tomlinson on you - though perhaps HS can give us his far more worthwhile opinion on the horn playing The singer was competent, but not transcendent. I wasn't moved the way Anthony Rolfe Johnson can move me in this work. All of it was easy enough o'the ear - apart from occasional lapses in the horn, and I bet it's a real git to play.

    Still, perhaps we should be grateful that Matey Tomlinson didn't crack a joke about the music giving Mozart and Britten 'the horn'.
    It loved to happen. -- Marcus Aurelius

    Comment

    • teamsaint
      Full Member
      • Nov 2010
      • 25210

      #3
      @Noggo, You may recall there was an excellent (and feisty) discussion about the G minor here.

      http://www.for3.org/forums/showthrea...ote-start-time!

      Look forward to catching up with this later. I know how I feel about #40.....for now.....
      I will not be pushed, filed, stamped, indexed, briefed, debriefed or numbered. My life is my own.

      I am not a number, I am a free man.

      Comment

      • EdgeleyRob
        Guest
        • Nov 2010
        • 12180

        #4
        Originally posted by edashtav View Post
        Royal Northern Sinfonia live from The Sage, Gateshead presented by Adam Tomlinson at 7.30pm Friday 25th October, 2013
        Werner Güra (tenor) Peter Francomb (horn) Thomas Zehetmair (conductor)

        Mozart: Divertimento in B flat 'Salzburg Symphony No. 2', K137
        Britten: Serenade for Tenor, Horn and Strings
        Mozart: Symphony No 40 in G minor, K550

        I’ve been catching up with this Concert little by little on iPlayer and have found a great deal to admire and am disappointed that no other For3 boarders seem to have bothered with it. It’s time, perhaps, to salute the great work done by Thomas Zehetmair over the last decade or more with “his” orchestra, especially as he intends to move in 2014 when he’ll assume the role of “conductor laureate” of this royal band.

        Why do I admire his work so? I think it’s because of the complete absence of dull routine. Every phrase and each blend of instrumental tone emerges fresh and brightly polished. Thomas is, of course, a great violinist and the orchestra has a winning string body that shows an ability to be light, marvellously unanimous but can burgeon into a rich refulgence when context so demands. This concert started with Mozart’s delightful Divertimento in Bb that was played beautifully with sprung rhythms to the fore together with a relaxed manner – players knew their parts well and communicated a sense that “we’re having fun”.

        It was good to hear Britten’s masterly Serenade sung in pretty idiomatic English by the young German tenor, Walter Gura. He exhibited a range of vocal timbres to suit the great variety of poetry in the seven songs. The excellent horn soloist was Peter Francomb, who is a member of the orchestra.

        Mozart’s 40th Symphony is very familiar but it came over newly imagined by Thomas Zahetmair. The first movement was quick, light and pointed. That might not please all listeners but the manner in which its style was unified from the smallest accompanying figure to full-blown climaxes was admirable. Zehetmair chose Mozart’s revised version with added clarinets.

        I’d characterise his whole approach as nearer to Robert Schumann’s concept that this G minor symphony is full of “Grecian lightness and grace", or Tovey’s idea that it's “opera buffa” than 20th century critics who huddle around Charles Rosen as he declares it “a work of passion, violence and grief”.

        Few days left on the iPlayer’s clock. I do commend these sparkling performances to you.
        I caught this over the weekend and thought it was superb Ed (silly announcer apart).
        I often listen to the evening concerts on catch up but am usually reluctant to post comments.
        I'd much rather read the brilliant reviews by yourself,JLW and others,the like of which is beyond me.

        Comment

        Working...
        X