If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.
Bournemouth Orchestra plays Walton 1st Symphony Tonight
Oh dear... a Walton One with mediocre sound, not enough fury and certainly not enough jazz... was the conductor getting in the players' way here perhaps? More than one hesitant and uncertain entry...
Previn's brilliant bullseye of a recording pinned this wild masterpiece down so completely, one feels a little sorry for all who come after, but still... brave effort tonight I'm sure, but - no cigar and certainly no champagne.
Oh dear... a Walton One with mediocre sound, not enough fury and certainly not enough jazz... was the conductor getting in the players' way here perhaps? More than one hesitant and uncertain entry...
Previn's brilliant bullseye of a recording pinned this wild masterpiece down so completely, one feels a little sorry for all who come after, but still... brave effort tonight I'm sure, but - no cigar and certainly no champagne.
Walton's 1st Symphony is a difficult work and the orchestra played all the notes, but was it the audience's tumultuous applause for that dreadful Rachmaninov performance that decided them to afford the "customers" no more than a "Brief Encounter" with the savagery and melancholy of Walton's masterpiece?
There must have been steam issuing from Silvestri's grave in St Peter's Churchyard during last night's concert. Even the Katchaturian ballet music failed to get off the ground.
HS
Last edited by Guest; 10-05-12, 07:52.
Reason: New keyboard
I shall play my Previn Walton sym 1 on LP. Sometimes the old ones are the best.
Always - the old ones are the best as you will find out when you get old.
I am at a most terrible disadvantage never having heard the Pervin Walton 1 or the Bournemouth under Silvestri but for once I managed to hear the full concert and enjoyed it - have far beyond the Pale how I gone I wonder????
Oh dear... a Walton One with mediocre sound, not enough fury and certainly not enough jazz... was the conductor getting in the players' way here perhaps? More than one hesitant and uncertain entry...
Previn's brilliant bullseye of a recording pinned this wild masterpiece down so completely, one feels a little sorry for all who come after, but still... brave effort tonight I'm sure, but - no cigar and certainly no champagne.
The conductor did say it was the first time he had performed it. 'So what?' - I suppose some will say.
I confess to never having really 'got' Walton, but I did buy his 2CD so-called 'Collected Works' [currently available for £5.77] thinking it might help. It includes the concerto recordings by Heifetz, Piatigorsky and Bashmet, the Sinfonia Concertante with Kathryn Stott/RPO/Handley and ..... Symphony No.1/LSO/Previn - so perhaps I should sit down again, dim the lights and see if he can persuade me!
"...the isle is full of noises,
Sounds and sweet airs, that give delight and hurt not.
Sometimes a thousand twangling instruments
Will hum about mine ears, and sometime voices..."
Comment