Nicola Benedetti

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • richardfinegold
    Full Member
    • Sep 2012
    • 7735

    Nicola Benedetti

    She was the Soloist in Prokofiev VC2 last night. I didn’t know much about her but it was a very memorable night. That piece has always been a bit of an ambivalent experience for me but she and MTT made it a compelling experience. She has a full bodied tone that projects well above the Orchestra.
    She encores with some sort of Scottish Variations on Auld Land Synge and she has a charming speaking voice. Unlike my experience in Edinburgh, I could understand every syllable.
    The Pathetique that followed was dry eyed Tchaikovsky in I and II, a rousing march greeted by the inevitable applause, but the performance seemed to be pointing towards the last movement, where everyone seemed to dig in and deliver unvarnished anguish. When the strings began the main theme of IV after the slow intro to the movement several people audibly gasped at the beautiful layer of sound. I haven’t heard this work in the Concert Hall for a while but it was the most satisfying concert of it, or perhaps any Tchaikovsky Symphony, that I have experienced.
    The concert began with a string Concerto by Stravinsky that was completely unknown to me. I had thought from the promo blurb that it was going to be the familiar Dumbarton Oaks but instead it was a neoclassical bit written for Paul Sacher’s Basle Orchestra. It was good to make the acquaintance and I would like to hear it again, any recommendations for a recording would be appreciated.
    At any rate after hearing works in which both Stravinsky and Prokofiev try to turn their backs on their earlier styles, it was great to conclude with some red blooded Tchaikovsky
  • cloughie
    Full Member
    • Dec 2011
    • 22180

    #2
    Originally posted by richardfinegold View Post
    She was the Soloist in Prokofiev VC2 last night. I didn’t know much about her but it was a very memorable night. That piece has always been a bit of an ambivalent experience for me but she and MTT made it a compelling experience. She has a full bodied tone that projects well above the Orchestra.
    She encores with some sort of Scottish Variations on Auld Land Synge and she has a charming speaking voice. Unlike my experience in Edinburgh, I could understand every syllable.
    The Pathetique that followed was dry eyed Tchaikovsky in I and II, a rousing march greeted by the inevitable applause, but the performance seemed to be pointing towards the last movement, where everyone seemed to dig in and deliver unvarnished anguish. When the strings began the main theme of IV after the slow intro to the movement several people audibly gasped at the beautiful layer of sound. I haven’t heard this work in the Concert Hall for a while but it was the most satisfying concert of it, or perhaps any Tchaikovsky Symphony, that I have experienced.
    The concert began with a string Concerto by Stravinsky that was completely unknown to me. I had thought from the promo blurb that it was going to be the familiar Dumbarton Oaks but instead it was a neoclassical bit written for Paul Sacher’s Basle Orchestra. It was good to make the acquaintance and I would like to hear it again, any recommendations for a recording would be appreciated.
    At any rate after hearing works in which both Stravinsky and Prokofiev try to turn their backs on their earlier styles, it was great to conclude with some red blooded Tchaikovsky
    Sounds like a great evening rfg. Nicola in addition to being a very good violinist is a great encourager of young musicians.

    Comment

    • richardfinegold
      Full Member
      • Sep 2012
      • 7735

      #3
      Originally posted by cloughie View Post
      Sounds like a great evening rfg. Nicola in addition to being a very good violinist is a great encourager of young musicians.
      She’s very charismatic

      Comment

      • LMcD
        Full Member
        • Sep 2017
        • 8634

        #4
        She was the 'BBC Young Musician Of The Year' in 2004 and is one of numerous very talented Scots with Italian connections or roots.

        Comment

        • richardfinegold
          Full Member
          • Sep 2012
          • 7735

          #5
          Originally posted by LMcD View Post
          She was the 'BBC Young Musician Of The Year' in 2004 and is one of numerous very talented Scots with Italian connections or roots.
          I was very frustrated with with the program notes. I knew that she was from your side of the Pond but not much else, and the notes didn’t even mention that. It was the usual list of where and with whom she has concertized and nothing useful at all about the Artist. Who writes these things?

          Comment

          • Richard Tarleton

            #6
            Originally posted by richardfinegold View Post
            She has a full bodied tone that projects well above the Orchestra.
            She encores with some sort of Scottish Variations on Auld Land Synge and she has a charming speaking voice. Unlike my experience in Edinburgh, I could understand every syllable.
            I'm delighted you had a good evening, rfg! I've only heard her once live (playing Szymanowski 2) but am a big fan. The ALS Variations are to be found on her "Homecoming - A Scottish Fantasy" disc, which is 50% the Bruch Scottish Fantasy and 50% Scottish traditional music with some distinguished collaborators - highly recommended. A fine performer, engaging personality and (in view of her educational work) all round good egg.

            Our own pastoraguy is best placed to tell you more about her.

            Comment

            • ferneyhoughgeliebte
              Gone fishin'
              • Sep 2011
              • 30163

              #7
              Originally posted by richardfinegold View Post
              The concert began with a string Concerto by Stravinsky that was completely unknown to me. I had thought from the promo blurb that it was going to be the familiar Dumbarton Oaks but instead it was a neoclassical bit written for Paul Sacher’s Basle Orchestra. It was good to make the acquaintance and I would like to hear it again, any recommendations for a recording would be appreciated.
              One of my favourite pieces by one of my favourite composers - infectiously joyous, and with one of the most beautiful "slow" movements. I'd thought that MTThad recorded it, but, if so, I can't find a copy. This is a good recording & performance:



              (Also available at twice the price, but with six other equally good discs of Stravinsky:

              [FONT=Comic Sans MS][I][B]Numquam Satis![/B][/I][/FONT]

              Comment

              • jayne lee wilson
                Banned
                • Jul 2011
                • 10711

                #8
                STRAVINSKY CONCERTO IN IN D....

                .
                I'd go for this recent anthology, as it is outstanding in each piece, and the Concerto in D as good as any I know...


                There is Stravinsky's own of course; excellent - that classic, close and dry, Stravinsky-Conducts-Stravinsky sound suits the work well - though it may be hard to find an individual album - most of the Sony/Columbia/CBC etc recordings are in larger boxes now... look hard enough, it's probably out there somewhere...

                Fond of the Honegger Symphonies 2 and 3, rfg? Some issues of the Karajan classic of these includes this Concerto in in D as well. Not quite a first choice for me, but still very good.


                Want all-Stravinsky? THIS is excellent, a Pet Sounds for me.... (same Concerto in D as on the Honegger disc)


                But my current top choice would be the BIS Suzuki...
                Last edited by jayne lee wilson; 16-12-18, 19:04.

                Comment

                • pastoralguy
                  Full Member
                  • Nov 2010
                  • 7799

                  #9
                  My first encounter with Ms. Benedetti was many years ago when I played at the back of an orchestra that was accompanying her in the Mendelssohn Concert when she was 14. She broke a string in the rehearsal so I followed her off stage and loaned her my A string which was quite new but well played in. She was very polite and charming and her subsequent success in the BBC YMoTY was very well deserved.

                  I've been lucky enough to meet her of many occasions and she always gives me a hug and reminds me of the 'A string incident!' Before I give my extremely humble opinion of her playing I will mention that she is a LOVELY individual who has brought tremendous credit to Scotland as well as being very involved in music education, concentrating on very deprived areas of Scotland that tend to be overlooked.

                  I've found it very interesting following her actual playing since I've heard her sound, technique and musical ability develop as her career has progressed. I must have heard her on, at least, 20 occasions, playing a wide range of repertoire from Telemann to the mighty DSCH Concerto No. 1. She's been equally convincing in all I've heard her play. (The only time I was VERY slightly disappointed was a live performance on TV of the Beethoven Concerto which I thought was ill advised since she had a slight memory lapse. Anyway, one shouldn't play the Beethoven Concerto before the age of forty anyway! )

                  Her sound has developed as she's got older and there's no doubt that having a marvellous Strad on loan helps. There were some sour comments when she won YMOTY due to her background which is very wealthy but I suspect it was sour grapes. The fact that she's very pretty also led to a bit of jealousy but so what?

                  I did speak to her about her ability developing as she's got older and she told me she just works very hard at her playing. I'm really looking forward to hearing her at 40! I'm not sure I would YET put her in the same league as Hilary Hahn or Janine Jansen to name but two of her peers but she's certainly catching them up!

                  Just some very random thoughts.

                  Comment

                  • LeMartinPecheur
                    Full Member
                    • Apr 2007
                    • 4717

                    #10
                    Another random thought: did RFG notice if her family provided the ice creams at his concert?
                    I keep hitting the Escape key, but I'm still here!

                    Comment

                    • Pulcinella
                      Host
                      • Feb 2014
                      • 11062

                      #11
                      Richard

                      You might find this 2CD set appealing, if you'd like to explore some of Stravinsky's less well known works:

                      Comment

                      • richardfinegold
                        Full Member
                        • Sep 2012
                        • 7735

                        #12
                        I was trying very hard to not mention that she is beautiful, a feature that was exceedingly difficult to ignore considering that our seats were 5th row main floor, but since PG opened that door...I found myself having to close my eyes so that I could try to exclude that factor from my evaluation of her playing, and I also listened to some of her You Tube (Audio only) excerpts that came from the BBC Competition. Her sound was different then, but whether that is due to Strad or due to aural limitations of You Tube compared with perspective last night I wouldn’t venture. Anyway, my wife’s first comment was
                        “What is she, a Size 2?” Mrs rfg was duly impressed by her and bought one of her discs from the Symphony Store at intermission.
                        So I gather that her family must be well off and in the ?dairy? business? She must inspire some resentments, being talented, beautiful, and from a background of privilege. I am assuming that vanquishes it through her charisma
                        Thanks to all for the Stravinsky recommendations. I had to double check my collection as I have a 2 disc set of Stravinsky conducting his own works for Columbia in mono, and haven’t played it in years, but it doesn’t contain the Concerto. Time to hit Apple Music and see what’s available. I might actually get the Karajan that Jane recommended as my Honegger collection is very sparse

                        Comment

                        • ferneyhoughgeliebte
                          Gone fishin'
                          • Sep 2011
                          • 30163

                          #13
                          Those Karajan/Honegger records are very special.

                          And you can "sample" the Stravinsky on youTube:

                          Provided to YouTube by Universal Music Group InternationalStravinsky: Concerto In D For String Orchestra - 1. Vivace · Berliner Philharmoniker · Herbert von ...


                          Provided to YouTube by Universal Music Group InternationalStravinsky: Concerto In D For String Orchestra - 2. Arioso. Andantino · Berliner Philharmoniker · H...


                          Provided to YouTube by Universal Music Group InternationalStravinsky: Concerto In D For String Orchestra - 3. Rondo. Allegro · Berliner Philharmoniker · Herb...
                          [FONT=Comic Sans MS][I][B]Numquam Satis![/B][/I][/FONT]

                          Comment

                          • jayne lee wilson
                            Banned
                            • Jul 2011
                            • 10711

                            #14
                            Very good value here for Igor's own, if you don't want the intégrale...
                            https://www.amazon.co.uk/Stravinsky-...nsky+concertos

                            Downloading off of BIS would give you the option of the Concerto in D on its own, with Suzuki...
                            Masaaki Suzuki is firmly established as a leading authority on the works of Bach, both in his capacity as director of the Bach Collegium Japan and as an organist and harpsichordist.
                            Last edited by jayne lee wilson; 16-12-18, 21:21.

                            Comment

                            • LeMartinPecheur
                              Full Member
                              • Apr 2007
                              • 4717

                              #15
                              Originally posted by richardfinegold View Post
                              So I gather that her family must be well off and in the ?dairy? business?
                              I'd thought that her family was big in ice cream but Google links their business more specifically to clingfilm! She herself says online:

                              “There are a lot of us. Many Italians came to Scotland during and after World War II, setting up small shops and businesses all over the country. You would be hard-pressed not to find at least one Italian restaurant or ice cream parlour in each little town or village. The national palate has become a little, shall we say, stronger it recent years. Food is a very big deal with Italians, and we take it very seriously.

                              “Speaking of which, I should get going here. I have a wee bit of time before my next interview, and I really must get something to eat.”
                              www.nicolabenedetti.co.uk
                              I keep hitting the Escape key, but I'm still here!

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X