Birtwistle and Maxwell Davies at QEH, London - 16.06.11

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • hackneyvi
    • Dec 2024

    Birtwistle and Maxwell Davies at QEH, London - 16.06.11

    I feel as if I may have heard a 'star is born' performance tonight in Peter Maxwell Davies' Eight Songs for a Mad King. The performer was Leigh Melrose.

    He was brought back on stage, I think, 4 times and absolutely deserved every clap and call from the audience. It was apparant in the singer's face - despite his modest manner - and that of his fellow players that they understood they'd reached the hall with their music.



    The Davies piece took up the second half. In my ignorance of it, I expected a very ironic or political piece in the Eight Songs. What I heard - and watched - was a completely compassionate, comic, tragic work in a performance fully but delicately expressing the delusion, disorientation, fragmentation and distress of a man gone mad. There's much extreme vocalising which had the rawness of the kind that contemporary composers and players tear out of their string instruments. But also a tenderness for the man by Leigh Melrose himself so that though there were comic moments, the King had nothing of indignity about him, only of affliction. It was an amazing performance; as much physical theatre as vocal and though it contained moments of lovely baritone song, a great deal of the singer's musicianship came from the integration of his facial, bodily and vocal delivery. A total performance; acting.

    The hall - though respectful from the beginning - became progressively clearly unified in attention and feeling. There were still snorts of laughter (I did this myself) but no twitches, no rustles, no breathing even. Truly, intently attending in silence. I've never been in a concert hall before and felt such common intent.
    Last edited by Guest; 17-06-11, 07:19.
  • Chris Newman
    Late Member
    • Nov 2010
    • 2100

    #2
    Hi Phil,
    I wish I was there. PM-D's Eight Songs are a tour-de-force I would love to hear again. I have heard Leigh Melrose with English Touring Opera: a lovely voice.

    Comment

    • hackneyvi

      #3
      This really was superb theatre, Chris; a wonderful piece of music theatre. I hope someone will film the Melrose/Sinfonietta performance because it absolutely deserves to be widely seen.

      I had NO idea.

      Comment

      • Chris Newman
        Late Member
        • Nov 2010
        • 2100

        #4
        Don't worry, Phil. I know it is fantastic theatre. I loved it when it first came out.

        I hope this brings back memories:

        Peter Maxwell Davies (1934-2016): Eight Songs for a Mad King, testo di Randolph Stow e King George III (1969).1. The Sentry (Tune: King Prussia's Minuet)2. T...


        Have you heard more recent PM-D? It is not quite so heavy metal.

        Best wishes,
        Chris.

        Comment

        • hackneyvi

          #5
          Originally posted by Chris Newman View Post
          Don't worry, Phil. I know it is fantastic theatre. I loved it when it first came out.

          I hope this brings back memories:

          Peter Maxwell Davies (1934-2016): Eight Songs for a Mad King, testo di Randolph Stow e King George III (1969).1. The Sentry (Tune: King Prussia's Minuet)2. T...


          Have you heard more recent PM-D? It is not quite so heavy metal.

          Best wishes,
          Chris.
          Sorry, Chris, I wasn't meaning to suggest you might not know but I went in completely unaware of what was coming.

          I've heard very little PMD but have been tempted to try the Naxos series of quartets. I think an element of Eight Songs appeal was the chamber-sized band.

          Do you have any suggestions?

          Comment

          • 3rd Viennese School

            #6
            Wot was the Birtwistle?

            P.S. Max is on tonight from 830pm ish. Throttle's nest or something.

            3VS

            Comment

            • hackneyvi

              #7
              Originally posted by 3rd Viennese School View Post
              Wot was the Birtwistle?

              3VS
              I'm glad you asked. Two pieces from Sir Birtwistle were programmed with Eight Songs as part of the Meltdown Festival, curated by Ray Davies (singer / songwriter with The Kinks).

              Firstly, at about 5 minutes long, there was Virelai - A score created by photocopying 2 completely different pieces of medieval music, one exactly on top of the other, from which - with exquisite care - some of the notes were taken out with Tippex. The result, as ever, was an extraordinary, radical and haunting new sound world.

              Following this was Secret Theatre. About which I have a story. It's not a very good story but it's true and, more important, it's the only one I've got. Bear with me.

              The auditorium was less than half-booked. So, I just bought the cheapest seat and made a dash for a better one when the lights dimmed. In fact, I upgraded from a seat right at the very back of the hall to the centre front row of the rear stalls and settled in a seat with several either side of me also free. I quickly realised that I couldn't quite see over the hair of a man directly in front of me on the back row of the front stalls. So, I hopped one seat to my left and had a wonderful, clear view.

              Now, this man (and his large, gray hair) was in a group of 5 people. The rest of their row was empty and so, I think, were the two rows in front of them. This struck me because I remembered seeing these rows as booked up when I'd looked on the QEH website at home. So, I thought, these seats are probably for guests, dignitaries, their friends and sundry other freeloaders subsidised by the taxpayer. Naturally, I wondered if one of these 5 might be Ray Davies himself.

              The 3 people to the left of the Hair were young; the Hair was broad and stout (which Ray Davies, to my knowledge, is not). This only left the small man on the right of the Hair but, whilst the small man's hair looked about right for Ray Davies - remember the hall is now in softish light - the small man himself seemed too small.

              I then began to suspect that the Hair was, in fact, Sir Birtwistle himself. But I put this out of my head because (honestly) the Hair didn't look as curly as the photos. But he was bearded, in a crumpled, cream, linen jacket, with fairly wavy hair and I began to believe it was indeed the world's greatest living composer. The Hair then turned to the girl on his left and it was He. (The small man next to him, too small to be Ray Davies, I beg her pardon but turned out to be Lady Sir Harrison Birtwistle, his wife.)

              I'm getting to the point. Secret Theatre started up. I couldn't really make anything much of it until, about 5 minutes before the end, when I remember the programme note talking about the main section of the orchestra playing ostinati. I then began to pick out a little of what they were doing. However, the piece, as you will know, has a second group which plays variously in 1 of 4 different types of unison and I found myself unable to hear one group of instruments when listening to the other. All came to naught.

              This was not painful music or a painful occasion but just, to me, meaningless music. And I pencilled on my programme: What human need does this satisfy? What's built with all this work? And just at that moment, Harrison Birtwistle, slowly and carefully, raised his left forearm up and looked at his watch.
              Last edited by Guest; 17-06-11, 17:25.

              Comment

              • Chris Newman
                Late Member
                • Nov 2010
                • 2100

                #8
                I occasionally see Sir Harrison make the same gesture when he and Lady B are shopping in our local supermarkets!

                I once saw him and his family on a summer holiday about twelve years ago standing around Sir John Betjeman's grave in a little churchyard set in the middle of a golf course near St Endellion in Cornwall.

                Comment

                • hackneyvi

                  #9
                  Originally posted by Chris Newman View Post
                  I occasionally see Sir Harrison make the same gesture when he and Lady B are shopping in our local supermarkets!
                  "How much longer will I have to be here?"
                  Do you think he went hoping to get Ray Davies' autograph?

                  I was bursting to shout out:

                  "Go on, Harrison, get up there and curtsy!"
                  But, something about Lady Sir Harrison seen from the side, though, put me in mind of Medusa and I just didn't dare.

                  Comment

                  • Serial_Apologist
                    Full Member
                    • Dec 2010
                    • 37812

                    #10
                    Originally posted by hackneyvi View Post
                    something about Lady Sir Harrison seen from the side, though, put me in mind of Medusa and I just didn't dare.
                    Was it two heads being better than one?

                    Comment

                    • Frances_iom
                      Full Member
                      • Mar 2007
                      • 2415

                      #11
                      Originally posted by 3rd Viennese School View Post
                      Wot was the Birtwistle?

                      P.S. Max is on tonight from 830pm ish. Throttle's nest or something.

                      3VS
                      Throstles nest Junction - (old english thrush I think) - used to pass it everyday on my way to school where the old Midland main line from Manchester Central to Derby/London branched away from the CLC line to Liverpool - almost across the tracks from the narrow platform that served Old Trafford (I think the MSJ&A might also have played a part) - I'm sure the Railway buffs will correct my now half century old memory.
                      Must admit tonight's presenter knew nothing about it (nor even the background to Mavis of Las Vegas)

                      Comment

                      • hackneyvi

                        #12
                        Originally posted by Serial_Apologist View Post
                        Was it two heads being better than one?
                        I rather beg her pardon because when I try to find out who she was, Sheila Birtwistle appears to have been ill for a number of years.

                        If you know the actress Judy Parfitt at her most severe, that was rather the impression I got. But I remember my mother often remarking that people with severe expressions in public are often simply thinking of other things, something Lady Birtwistle and I may have had in common last night.

                        PS: I strongly suspect somebody said this to my mother of herself. She wouldn't have liked the idea of that, at all.

                        Comment

                        • 3rd Viennese School

                          #13
                          Heard the Throttle Neck Junction. Unusual having a symphonic Poem described as light music. Last Friday the girl didn’t say when this was composed- is this a new work?

                          The work did remind me of a train junction- a bit like the one here in Strood, Kent. Screeech.
                          It’s been recorded so I can listen to it again.


                          Message 7
                          The Birtwistle Virelai sounds like an interesting idea of working. Was it non- vocal?

                          I have Secret Theatre and it’s been played quite a few times- but I still can’t hum any of it. The end of the piece is supposed to be a reference to that song “What the world needs now” but I can only take HB’s word for it at the moment until it’s played again!

                          P.S. Ray Davies also wrote music for the Channel 4 testcard!

                          3VS

                          Comment

                          • umslopogaas
                            Full Member
                            • Nov 2010
                            • 1977

                            #14
                            'Eight Songs For A Mad King' is a powerful and disturbing piece. I've never heard it live, but I have a recording on LP (Unicorn UNS 261) dating from 1971. Julius Eastman (soloist) and the Fires of London, conducted by the composer. I dont know if it ever made it to CD: there are no versions of the piece listed in either the 2005/6 or the 2010 Penguin Guides. The record sleeve says "A Ken Russell Production" but it doesnt say what he did.

                            Comment

                            • arcades

                              #15
                              Originally posted by umslopogaas View Post
                              'Eight Songs For A Mad King' is a powerful and disturbing piece. I've never heard it live, but I have a recording on LP (Unicorn UNS 261) dating from 1971. Julius Eastman (soloist) and the Fires of London, conducted by the composer. I dont know if it ever made it to CD: there are no versions of the piece listed in either the 2005/6 or the 2010 Penguin Guides. The record sleeve says "A Ken Russell Production" but it doesnt say what he did.
                              It did make it to CD, yes, but has been unavailable for a while. Intriguingly there is a recording in this set

                              Discover Spannungen: Musik im Kraftwerk Heimbach [Limited Edition] by Lars Vogt released in 2007. Find album reviews, track lists, credits, awards and more at AllMusic.


                              (I've not heard it). I agree Eight Songs is quite an experience. Off-topic (sorry!) but if you like the Maxwell Davies do try to hear David Lumsdaine's very different but inwardly theatrical Aria for Edward John Eyre, which is truly amazing (great composer, IMO). http://www.mdt.co.uk/MDTSite/product//NMCD007.htm

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X